Noctua NH-U12S Redux vs Noctua NM-i17xx-MP78

Overview of the Noctua NH-U12S Redux

The Noctua NH-U12S Redux is a streamlined and more affordable version of the award-winning NH-U12S heatsink, priced at C$62.95. This cooler is designed for excellent compatibility with various cases and motherboards. Its slim 120mm size ensures that it fits most tower cases without overhanging the RAM slots or blocking PCIe slots on most ATX and Micro-ATX motherboards. The NH-U12S Redux is equipped with a quiet NF-P12 redux-1700 120mm fan that uses PWM for automatic speed control, delivering full cooling performance under load while remaining nearly silent at idle.

Overview of the Noctua NM-i17xx-MP78

The Noctua NM-i17xx-MP78 is a mounting upgrade kit priced at just C$12.95. This kit is specifically designed for Noctua CPU coolers with a 78mm mounting pitch, facilitating their installation on Intel’s LGA1851 and LGA1700 sockets. It features a dedicated one-piece backplate with fixed struts that ensures optimal contact pressure and reliability. The NM-i17xx-MP78 allows for straightforward installation, enabling users to install the cooler turned by 90° if space permits, thus providing additional versatility during setup.

Compatibility

Compatibility is a significant aspect when choosing CPU cooling solutions. The NH-U12S Redux is designed to fit most tower cases with a height of 158mm, making it suitable for a wide range of builds. It supports a variety of socket types, including Intel LGA1851, LGA1700, LGA1200, and LGA115x, as well as AMD AM5 and AM4. On the other hand, the NM-i17xx-MP78 specifically targets users with Noctua CPU coolers who need to mount them on Intel's newer LGA1851 and LGA1700 sockets. This kit allows existing cooler owners to upgrade their mounting systems at a low cost, which could be a deciding factor for users looking to adapt their setup without investing in a new cooler.

Performance

When it comes to performance, the NH-U12S Redux stands out with its efficient cooling capabilities. The NF-P12 redux-1700 fan provides excellent airflow while maintaining a near-silent operation. This cooler is particularly effective under load, ensuring that high-performance CPUs remain cool during intensive tasks. In contrast, the NM-i17xx-MP78 does not offer cooling performance on its own, as it is solely a mounting kit. Its role is to enhance the compatibility of existing Noctua coolers with newer Intel sockets, making it an essential accessory for users looking to maintain high performance with their current cooling solution.

Installation Process

Installation is straightforward for both products, but they serve different purposes. The NH-U12S Redux comes with a SecuFirm2 mounting system that simplifies the installation on various socket types, making it accessible for users of all experience levels. Its included high-end NT-H1 thermal paste further aids in achieving optimal performance. Conversely, the NM-i17xx-MP78 is designed for easy installation, featuring a dedicated backplate and fixed struts that ensure reliable mounting. While the NH-U12S Redux is a complete cooling solution, the NM-i17xx-MP78 focuses on enabling compatibility with newer sockets, making the installation process seamless for those upgrading their setups.

Price Comparison

Price is a critical factor when making purchasing decisions. The NH-U12S Redux is positioned at C$62.95, reflecting its comprehensive cooling capabilities and compatibility features. This price point is justified given its performance and the quality associated with the Noctua brand. In stark contrast, the NM-i17xx-MP78 is significantly more affordable at C$12.95. This low-cost upgrade option makes it an attractive choice for users who already own a compatible Noctua cooler and need a simple solution to adapt to newer Intel sockets without incurring high costs.

Brand Reputation

Noctua has built a solid reputation within the PC cooling market, known for its high-quality products that deliver reliable performance and longevity. The NH-U12S Redux continues this tradition, offering users a well-regarded cooling solution at a competitive price. The brand's commitment to quality is also evident in the NM-i17xx-MP78, which is designed to enhance the usability of existing coolers. Both products reflect Noctua's dedication to providing innovative solutions for PC builders, ensuring that users can expect dependable performance from whichever product they choose.

Which should you buy?

Choosing between the Noctua NH-U12S Redux and the Noctua NM-i17xx-MP78 ultimately depends on your specific needs. If you require a complete cooling solution with excellent performance and compatibility across various socket types, the NH-U12S Redux at C$62.95 is the better option. However, if you already own a Noctua cooler and are looking for an affordable way to upgrade to Intel’s LGA1851 or LGA1700 sockets, the NM-i17xx-MP78 priced at C$12.95 is a sensible choice. Each product serves distinct purposes, so your decision should be guided by whether you need a new cooler or simply an upgrade for an existing one.