Thermalright LGA1700-BCF Black V2 CPU Retainer vs Thermalright AXP90 X47 Full Low Profile CPU Cooler

Overview of the Products

In the realm of CPU cooling solutions, the Thermalright LGA1700-BCF Black V2 CPU Retainer and the Thermalright AXP90 X47 Full Low Profile CPU Cooler present distinct functionalities and price points. The LGA1700-BCF Black V2 is priced at C$8.99, while the AXP90 X47 carries a significantly higher price of C$43.39. This difference in cost reflects their intended use and features, making them suitable for different types of users and builds.

The LGA1700-BCF Black V2 serves as a sturdy retainer designed specifically for Intel's LGA1700 socket, focusing on preventing CPU bending during cooler installation. In contrast, the AXP90 X47 is a full low-profile cooler that promises efficient cooling for compact builds, appealing to users who require high-performance cooling in smaller form factors.

Design and Build Quality

The design and build quality of both products highlight their respective purposes. The LGA1700-BCF Black V2 is constructed from an all-aluminium alloy, weighing 55 grams and measuring 54x70x6mm. This lightweight material is intended to provide adequate support for CPU coolers while ensuring durability against bending.

On the other hand, the AXP90 X47 boasts a low-profile design with a height of just 47mm, making it exceptionally suitable for HTPCs and ITX builds. Its dimensions of 94.5x95x47mm ensure that it can fit into tight spaces while still delivering robust cooling performance. The cooler also employs pure copper for its radiator, enhancing its oxidation resistance and overall efficiency.

Cooling Performance

When it comes to cooling performance, the AXP90 X47 clearly has the upper hand. With its AGHP technology, the cooler features four 6mm heat pipes that effectively manage heat dissipation, even when oriented vertically or horizontally. This technology effectively doubles the cooling potential compared to traditional methods.

In contrast, the LGA1700-BCF Black V2 does not provide cooling directly but rather supports the installation of CPU coolers, ensuring they do not bend the CPU. Therefore, while it plays a crucial role in maintaining the integrity of the CPU during setup, it does not offer any active cooling capabilities. Users looking for performance will likely lean towards the AXP90 X47.

Installation Process

Both products are designed with user-friendliness in mind, but they cater to different installation needs. The LGA1700-BCF Black V2 comes with an L-shaped screwdriver, facilitating an easy installation process for the retainer. Along with clear instructions and the option to consult customer service, this product promises a straightforward setup.

Conversely, the AXP90 X47 also emphasizes ease of installation, offering compatibility with a variety of CPU sockets, including LGA1700, LGA1150, LGA1151, and AMD AM4/AM5, among others. The cooler is equipped with metal mounting fasteners and includes a manual for guidance. While both products aim to simplify their respective installations, the AXP90 X47 caters to a broader audience with varying CPU socket requirements.

Compatibility

In terms of compatibility, the LGA1700-BCF Black V2 is specifically designed for Intel's 12th to 14th generation CPUs, which utilize the LGA1700 socket. It supports motherboards with chipsets such as H610, B660, B760, Z690, and Z790, making it a focused solution for users within this specific ecosystem.

On the other hand, the AXP90 X47 offers broader compatibility across various platforms. It supports Intel CPUs across several sockets, including LGA1700 and previous generations, as well as AMD platforms like AM4 and AM5. This versatility makes the AXP90 X47 appealing to a wider range of users, particularly those who may switch between platforms or upgrade their systems.

Noise Levels

Noise levels are a crucial factor for many users, especially those building home theatre PCs or silent systems. The AXP90 X47 operates at a noise level of 22.4dB (A), which is relatively quiet, allowing it to run unobtrusively in noise-sensitive environments. Additionally, it features a 92mm PWM fan that adjusts speed based on temperature, further contributing to its quiet operation.

In contrast, the LGA1700-BCF Black V2 does not have a noise specification as it does not include any active cooling components. Its effectiveness lies in its structural support rather than sound management. Therefore, for users who prioritize silence along with cooling performance, the AXP90 X47 is the clear winner.

Price Point

There is a notable difference in price between the two products, which reflects their intended usage. The LGA1700-BCF Black V2 is priced at C$8.99, making it a budget-friendly option for those who require a retainer without the need for active cooling. This makes it an attractive choice for users who are assembling their systems and require a reliable support mechanism.

In contrast, the AXP90 X47 is priced at C$43.39, positioning it as a more premium option aimed at users seeking effective cooling solutions in compact builds. While it may be a higher investment, the advanced technology, broad compatibility, and performance it offers could justify the cost for serious builders.

Which should you buy?

Choosing between the Thermalright LGA1700-BCF Black V2 CPU Retainer and the Thermalright AXP90 X47 Full Low Profile CPU Cooler ultimately comes down to your specific needs and build requirements. If you're simply looking for a reliable retainer for your Intel LGA1700 CPU to prevent bending during cooler installation, the LGA1700-BCF Black V2 is an economical choice at C$8.99. However, if you require a robust cooling solution in a compact form factor, the AXP90 X47, priced at C$43.39, offers superior performance, compatibility, and quiet operation. For those serious about maintaining optimal CPU temperatures, the AXP90 X47 is the clear choice.