Thermalright PS120SE CPU Air Cooler vs Noctua NH-U12S Redux

Brand Overview

When it comes to CPU coolers, both Thermalright and Noctua are reputable brands with their unique strengths. Thermalright, a Taiwanese brand with over 20 years of experience, is known for its focus on research and development in computer accessories, including CPU coolers. On the other hand, Noctua has made a name for itself by producing high-quality, efficient cooling solutions, emphasising performance and acoustics.

Thermalright's PS120SE CPU Air Cooler is priced at C$44.90, positioning it as a more budget-friendly option. In contrast, the Noctua NH-U12S Redux comes in at C$62.95, reflecting its premium branding and performance reputation. While both brands cater to the needs of gamers and PC builders, their pricing suggests differing target markets, with Thermalright aiming for those seeking value without sacrificing quality.

Cooling Performance

The Thermalright PS120SE boasts impressive cooling capabilities, supporting a thermal design power (TDP) range from 105W to 280W. This wide range indicates that the cooler can effectively manage heat dissipation for a variety of CPUs. The advanced AGHP technique used in its construction enables efficient thermal transfer, making it a robust choice for demanding applications.

Conversely, the Noctua NH-U12S Redux features the renowned NF-P12 redux-1700 fan, which operates quietly and offers PWM control for optimised speed management. While the specific TDP rating isn't mentioned, Noctua's design philosophy prioritises both cooling performance and low noise levels, making it a solid option for users who value a quiet computing experience. Thus, users looking for extreme cooling might lean toward Thermalright, while those prioritising quiet operation may prefer Noctua.

Design and Build Quality

In terms of design, the Thermalright PS120SE features a height of 154mm and dimensions of 125mm by 135mm, allowing compatibility with a broad range of chassis models. The cooler's construction includes an anodised black frosted top and a finely carved pure copper base, contributing to its aesthetic appeal and thermal efficiency.

On the other hand, the Noctua NH-U12S Redux is designed with a slim profile, standing at 158mm tall, which ensures compatibility with most tower cases while avoiding interference with RAM slots and PCIe slots. This design consideration allows for versatile installation options. Both coolers reflect high build quality, but Noctua's design may provide more flexibility in tighter builds, while Thermalright focuses on robust materials for optimal heat dissipation.

Fan Performance

The PWM fan in the Thermalright PS120SE, the TL-C12B V2, operates at a maximum speed of 1500 RPM, delivering an airflow of 66.17 CFM while maintaining a noise level of ≤25.6 dB(A). This demonstrates a well-balanced performance, ensuring effective cooling without excessive noise, which is crucial for a serene computing environment.

In contrast, the Noctua NH-U12S Redux's NF-P12 redux-1700 fan is engineered for quiet operation, and while specific airflow figures aren’t provided, its design allows for full cooling performance under load while remaining silent at idle. This makes it particularly appealing for users who prioritise low noise levels, especially in settings like home offices or gaming rigs. Both fans are commendable, but the choice hinges on whether users favour maximum airflow or minimal noise.

Compatibility

Compatibility is a significant consideration for CPU coolers, and both the Thermalright PS120SE and Noctua NH-U12S Redux offer extensive support for various CPU sockets. The Thermalright cooler supports Intel sockets LGA1700, LGA1851, and multiple older versions, along with AMD AM4 and AM5. This compatibility is crucial for users planning to upgrade their CPUs in the future.

The Noctua NH-U12S Redux also supports a wide range of sockets, including Intel LGA1851, LGA1700, LGA1200, and LGA115x, as well as AMD AM4 and AM5. The inclusion of the SecuFirm2 mounting system in Noctua’s cooler enhances ease of installation, which could be particularly beneficial for novice builders. Both coolers excel in compatibility, but Noctua’s user-friendly installation system may give it a slight edge for those less experienced in PC building.

Thermal Paste

Thermal paste quality can significantly impact cooling performance, and the Thermalright PS120SE does not specify whether it includes thermal paste. However, it does highlight high thermal conductivity in its design, suggesting careful consideration of thermal transfer.

In contrast, the Noctua NH-U12S Redux comes with high-end NT-H1 thermal paste, which is well-regarded in the PC building community for its performance and ease of application. The inclusion of this premium thermal paste can enhance the cooler's efficiency right out of the box. Users looking for a comprehensive cooling solution may find Noctua's inclusion of thermal paste a beneficial addition.

Price Comparison

Price is a crucial factor when choosing between CPU coolers. The Thermalright PS120SE is priced at C$44.90, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious consumers who do not want to compromise on performance. This price point allows for a solid balance of affordability and quality, appealing to a broader audience.

The Noctua NH-U12S Redux, on the other hand, is priced at C$62.95, reflecting its reputation for high performance and quality. While it is pricier, many users may be willing to pay the extra cost for the brand's proven track record of reliability and quiet operation. Ultimately, the decision may come down to the consumer's budget and specific cooling needs.

Which should you buy?

Choosing between the Thermalright PS120SE and Noctua NH-U12S Redux ultimately depends on your specific needs and budget. If you are looking for an affordable cooling solution that offers solid performance and a wide TDP range, the Thermalright PS120SE is a commendable choice. However, if you value quiet operation, ease of installation, and high-quality thermal paste, the Noctua NH-U12S Redux may be worth the additional investment. Both coolers present strong cases, but your individual requirements will guide the final decision.