Thermalright TL-C12CW-S X3 CPU Fan 120mm White ARGB Case Cooler Fan vs Thermalright LGA1700-BCF Black V2 CPU Retainer

Overview of the Products

In this comparison, we will evaluate two offerings from Thermalright: the Thermalright TL-C12CW-S X3 CPU Fan and the Thermalright LGA1700-BCF Black V2 CPU Retainer. The former is a cooling fan designed to enhance airflow in your system, while the latter is a retainer that secures the CPU and prevents potential bending. The TL-C12CW-S X3 is priced at C$17.99, whereas the LGA1700-BCF Black V2 is more budget-friendly at C$8.99.

Design and Build Quality

The design and build quality of both products reflect Thermalright's commitment to performance and durability. The TL-C12CW-S X3 features a 120mm frame and is equipped with quality S-FDB bearings, which minimize noise while maximizing cooling efficiency. This model also incorporates ARGB lighting, providing up to 17 modes of light effects that can be synchronized with the motherboard. On the other hand, the LGA1700-BCF Black V2 is constructed from an all-aluminium alloy, ensuring a sturdy build that supports the cooler's weight while preventing CPU bending. Its anodized sandblasting finish not only enhances aesthetics but also increases durability.

Cooling Performance

Cooling performance is a critical aspect where the TL-C12CW-S X3 excels. With a maximum speed of 1550 RPM and an airflow capacity of 66.17 CFM, this fan can deliver substantial cooling to your CPU and case, ensuring optimal performance. The fan's noise level is kept at a minimum of 25.6 dBA, providing a silent operation without compromising cooling efficiency. In contrast, the LGA1700-BCF Black V2 does not directly contribute to cooling but rather supports the CPU's stability, which indirectly affects thermal performance by ensuring the cooler sits correctly.

Installation Process

The installation process differs significantly between the two products. The TL-C12CW-S X3 connects via a 4-pin PWM cable, allowing it to be controlled by the motherboard based on temperature readings. The fan comes with a generous 55cm cable, facilitating easy routing within the case. In comparison, the LGA1700-BCF Black V2 is designed for straightforward installation, coming with an L-shaped screwdriver and a user-friendly setup process. It is compatible with Intel's 12th to 14th generation CPUs, making it a practical choice for those upgrading or building a new system.

Noise Levels

Noise levels are an essential consideration for any cooling solution. The TL-C12CW-S X3 operates at a maximum noise level of 25.6 dBA, which is relatively quiet compared to standard fans. This low noise output makes it suitable for gaming and professional environments where concentration is critical. The LGA1700-BCF Black V2, while not a cooling fan itself, contributes to a quieter operation by ensuring that the CPU cooler is securely mounted, preventing unwanted vibrations that could increase noise levels.

Compatibility

In terms of compatibility, the TL-C12CW-S X3 is versatile enough to be used as both a case fan and a CPU cooler fan, making it a great addition to various setups. It can easily fit into standard 120mm fan mounts, providing flexibility for users. Meanwhile, the LGA1700-BCF Black V2 is specifically designed for Intel's LGA1700 socket, which includes motherboards like H610, B660, and Z790. This targeted compatibility ensures that it effectively supports the cooler while preventing CPU bending, a common issue with heavy coolers.

Aesthetics

The aesthetics of a product can be as important as its performance for many users. The TL-C12CW-S X3 features high-brightness LED lighting that enhances the visual appeal of a build, making it suitable for gaming setups where aesthetics matter. It offers a soft ARGB effect that can be synchronized with other components. In contrast, the LGA1700-BCF Black V2 opts for a more utilitarian look, focusing on functionality rather than flashy designs. While it may not contribute to visual flair, its sleek black finish still provides a clean and professional appearance.

Price Comparison

Price is a significant factor when choosing between these two products. The Thermalright TL-C12CW-S X3 is priced at C$17.99, reflecting its advanced features and cooling capabilities. In comparison, the LGA1700-BCF Black V2 is considerably cheaper at C$8.99, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious builders who need a reliable CPU retainer without the added features of a fan. This price difference illustrates the value proposition of each product based on its intended use.

Which should you buy?

Choosing between the Thermalright TL-C12CW-S X3 CPU Fan and the LGA1700-BCF Black V2 CPU Retainer largely depends on your specific needs. If you're looking for a high-performance cooling solution with aesthetic appeal and excellent airflow, the TL-C12CW-S X3 is the better choice. However, if your primary concern is ensuring your CPU remains securely in place to prevent bending, particularly when using heavyweight coolers, the LGA1700-BCF Black V2 offers a cost-effective and efficient solution. Consider your setup and what features are most important to you before making a decision.