Amazon Basics ‎MD023 Full-Sized Wireless Keyboard and Mouse Combo vs ProtoArc Backlit Compact Bluetooth Keyboard and Mouse for Mac

Design and Aesthetics

The Amazon Basics MD023 Full-Sized Wireless Keyboard and Mouse Combo features a sleek black design that integrates seamlessly with existing technology and decor. In contrast, the ProtoArc Backlit Compact Bluetooth Keyboard and Mouse offers a compact design that resembles Apple's Magic Keyboard, specifically tailored for Mac users.

While the Amazon Basics set maintains a standard UK keyboard layout, the ProtoArc is designed exclusively for Mac devices. The compact layout of the ProtoArc not only saves desk space but also enhances portability, making it ideal for users who travel. In terms of aesthetics, the ProtoArc's backlit keys provide a modern touch, especially useful in low-light environments, setting it apart from the more traditional design of the Amazon Basics set.

Compatibility and Connectivity

The Amazon Basics combo connects via a 2.4 GHz USB receiver, ensuring a straightforward plug-and-play experience compatible with various Windows operating systems. It supports Windows versions from 2000 to 10/11, providing broad compatibility for users. However, it requires users to use a single USB receiver for both the keyboard and mouse, which might limit connectivity options.

On the other hand, the ProtoArc is specifically designed for Apple devices, being compatible with MacBook Pro, MacBook Air, iPad, and iPhone. It connects via Bluetooth, allowing for seamless multi-device connectivity with the ability to switch between three Bluetooth channels effortlessly. This makes the ProtoArc a more versatile choice for Mac users who often work across multiple devices.

Battery Life and Power Source

The Amazon Basics keyboard and mouse require a total of three batteries: one AA for the mouse and two AAA for the keyboard, which are included with the purchase. While this offers a ready-to-use solution, it does mean ongoing battery replacements in the future.

In contrast, the ProtoArc features a built-in rechargeable battery, with a capacity of 1200mAh for the keyboard and 500mAh for the mouse. This eco-friendly design not only reduces the need for disposable batteries but also includes a sleep mode that activates after 60 minutes of inactivity, conserving energy. Users can recharge the devices using the included cable, although it cannot be used for data transmission. The rechargeable nature of the ProtoArc potentially offers a more sustainable choice in the long run.

Performance and Typing Experience

The Amazon Basics MD023 is a full-sized keyboard and mouse combo, providing a standard typing experience that many users may find familiar and comfortable. The keys offer a decent tactile feedback suitable for everyday tasks, making it a practical choice for general use.

In comparison, the ProtoArc boasts a low-profile scissor mechanism for its keys, which is designed to enhance the typing experience. This mechanism not only provides responsive typing but also contributes to a quieter operation. Additionally, the ProtoArc mouse features three adjustable DPI levels (1000/1600/2400), allowing users to customise sensitivity based on their preferences, which is a significant advantage for users who require precision in their tasks.

Backlighting and Customisation

The Amazon Basics combo does not feature backlighting, which may limit usability in low-light conditions. Its standard design is straightforward and functional, appealing to users who prefer simplicity without additional features.

In contrast, the ProtoArc offers customizable backlighting with three soft white LED brightness levels. This feature reduces eye strain and enhances visibility in various lighting environments, making it particularly appealing for those who often work in dimly lit settings. The ability to adjust the brightness adds a layer of personalisation that many users may find beneficial, especially for longer typing sessions.

Pricing and Value

The Amazon Basics MD023 is priced at £17.99, making it an affordable option for those looking for a reliable keyboard and mouse combo without breaking the bank. This price point makes it accessible for students, home office users, and anyone needing a functional device for basic tasks.

In comparison, the ProtoArc is significantly more expensive at £49.99. While this higher price tag reflects its advanced features such as Bluetooth connectivity, backlighting, and a rechargeable battery, it may not be justifiable for users who only require basic functionality. The value of each product will largely depend on the specific needs and preferences of the user.

Which should you buy?

The choice between the Amazon Basics MD023 Full-Sized Wireless Keyboard and Mouse Combo and the ProtoArc Backlit Compact Bluetooth Keyboard and Mouse ultimately depends on your specific requirements. If you need a straightforward, budget-friendly option that works seamlessly with Windows systems, the Amazon Basics combo is a solid choice. However, if you are a Mac user seeking a compact, feature-rich experience with backlighting and multi-device connectivity, the ProtoArc presents a more suitable solution, albeit at a higher price point. Consider your device compatibility, typing preferences, and budget when making your decision.