Fladen Warbird 3100 Multiplier Reel Right Handed vs Avid Revolve 12000FD Lightweight Big Pit Carp Fishing Reel

Price Comparison

The Fladen Warbird 3100 Multiplier Reel is priced at £59.00, while the Avid Revolve 12000FD Lightweight Big Pit Carp Fishing Reel comes in at £50.49. This means the Fladen reel is £8.51 more expensive than the Avid model. For anglers on a budget, the Avid Revolve offers a more economical choice without compromising on essential features. However, the price difference may reflect the specific functionalities and build quality that each reel provides, which could be worth considering based on individual fishing needs.

Build Quality and Durability

In terms of construction, the Fladen Warbird features a robust graphite body combined with an aluminium spool and handle, ensuring it can withstand demanding beach conditions. The Avid Revolve also boasts a durable graphite body and rotor, finished in a sleek matte black with gloss detailing, contributing to its longevity. Both reels are designed to endure the rigours of fishing, but the Fladen's aluminium components may provide an edge in durability, particularly for surfcasting applications. The Warbird weighs 648g, while the Revolve is lighter at 577g, which may affect comfort during extended fishing sessions.

Fishing Style Suitability

The Fladen Warbird is engineered specifically for surfcasting in the UK, featuring a gear ratio of 4.1:1, designed to facilitate long-range casting. This makes it ideal for beach and mixed ground fishing where distance is often crucial. Conversely, the Avid Revolve, with a higher gear ratio of 4.6:1, is tailored for modern carp angling, presenting a versatile option for various fishing scenarios. It offers a line capacity of 0.40mm/310m, 0.35mm/400m, and 0.30mm/550m, making it adaptable to different fishing techniques and conditions. Depending on your fishing style, one of these reels may prove to be more beneficial than the other.

Casting Performance

Casting performance is a vital consideration for any fishing reel. The Fladen Warbird features a no-level wind design, which enhances casting distance, making it a strong contender for anglers looking to maximise their range. It is equipped with 2+1 stainless steel ball bearings, which contribute to a smooth operation. The Avid Revolve, on the other hand, utilises a slow oscillation worm-shaft system that ensures flawless line lay, thereby improving casting distance as well. With 5 + 1 stainless steel ball bearings, it also promises a smooth experience. Both reels offer excellent casting capabilities, yet the specific design features may appeal differently based on the angler's preferences.

Drag System

The drag systems of both reels are designed for user convenience and performance. The Fladen Warbird incorporates a star drag system, allowing for precise control during fights with fish, making it particularly effective in challenging surf conditions. In contrast, the Avid Revolve is equipped with a rapid front drag system that includes twin line-friendly clips for quick adjustments. This feature is particularly beneficial for carp anglers who need to make swift changes during their fishing sessions. Each drag system has its advantages, catering to different styles and preferences, which could influence an angler's choice depending on their typical fishing scenarios.

Weight and Ergonomics

Weight is an important factor for comfort during prolonged use. The Fladen Warbird weighs 648g, which is slightly heavier than the Avid Revolve at 577g. The lighter design of the Avid reel may provide improved ergonomics, particularly for anglers who spend long hours fishing. Furthermore, the Avid model features a black anodised aluminium handle with a soft-touch knob, enhancing grip and comfort during use. While the Fladen is built for durability, the Avid's lighter weight and ergonomic considerations make it a more comfortable option for extended fishing sessions.

Line Capacity and Versatility

The line capacity of a reel can significantly influence its versatility across different fishing methods. The Fladen Warbird has a line capacity of 420yds/20lbs or 320m/0.45mm, which is suitable for surfcasting. On the other hand, the Avid Revolve offers a line capacity of 0.30mm/550m, 0.35mm/400m, and 0.40mm/310m, which makes it more adaptable for various carp fishing situations. The Avid's multiple spool options, including a spare deep spool available separately, provide further versatility for anglers looking to tackle different environments or fish sizes. This variability might make the Avid a more appealing choice for those who frequently switch between fishing types.

Which should you buy?

Choosing between the Fladen Warbird 3100 Multiplier Reel and the Avid Revolve 12000FD Lightweight Big Pit Carp Fishing Reel ultimately comes down to your specific fishing needs. If you require a reel tailored for surfcasting with a robust build and long-range capabilities, the Fladen Warbird may be your best bet, albeit at a higher price point. However, if you're looking for a lightweight, versatile reel suitable for modern carp angling, the Avid Revolve stands out with its economical price and user-friendly features. Assessing your fishing style and preferences will help you make the best decision between these two excellent options.