Logitech MX Master 3S - Wireless Performance Mouse with Ultra-fast Scrolling vs Logitech M171 Wireless Mouse for PC

Overview of the Logitech MX Master 3S and Logitech M171

The Logitech MX Master 3S is a premium performance mouse priced at £68.99, while the Logitech M171 is a budget-friendly option available for £13.99. The significant price difference reflects their intended use and feature sets. The MX Master 3S is designed for serious productivity with advanced features, whereas the M171 serves as a practical solution for everyday tasks.

Design and Comfort

The MX Master 3S boasts an ergonomic design aimed at providing comfort during prolonged use. Its silhouette is crafted to promote a more natural wrist posture, making it ideal for office workers and designers. In contrast, the M171 features a comfortable and mobile shape that is ambidextrous, catering to both left and right-handed users. While the MX Master 3S is specifically designed for extensive use, the M171 prioritises portability and ease of use, making it easy to store in a bag.

Connectivity Options

The MX Master 3S offers versatile connectivity, allowing users to connect up to three devices via Bluetooth, accommodating various operating systems including Windows, macOS, Chrome OS, and Linux. It also supports FLOW cross-computer control, enabling seamless workflow across multiple devices. The M171, on the other hand, utilises a straightforward plug-and-play USB receiver, connecting within three seconds. This simplicity is advantageous for users who prefer a quick setup without additional software.

Performance Features

A standout feature of the MX Master 3S is its 8K DPI sensor, which supports any-surface tracking, including glass. This high precision is complemented by Magspeed scrolling, which is reported to be 90% faster and 87% more precise than traditional scrolling methods. The M171, while less sophisticated, provides reliable performance with smooth cursor control across various surfaces thanks to its optical tracking. However, it operates at a lower level of sensitivity and precision compared to the MX Master 3S.

Battery Life and Power Management

The MX Master 3S features a rechargeable battery, offering a convenient solution for users who want to avoid frequent battery changes. In contrast, the M171 runs on AA batteries with an impressive 12-month battery life and an auto-sleep feature to conserve energy. This makes the M171 a practical choice for users who prefer minimal maintenance and want a mouse that can last long without the need for recharging.

Customisation and Software

The MX Master 3S excels in customisation options, allowing users to optimise their workflow with app-specific profiles via the Logi Options+ app. This feature enables users to assign functions to buttons according to their personal or work needs. The M171, however, lacks this level of customisation, focusing instead on providing essential functionality without the need for additional software. This simplicity may appeal to users who do not require extensive features.

Noise Level and User Experience

When it comes to noise, the MX Master 3S is designed with Quiet Clicks technology, which reduces click noise by 90%, providing a more discreet user experience. This is particularly beneficial in quiet environments where noise can be disruptive. The M171, while not specifically designed for silent operation, provides a typical mouse clicking experience that may be more noticeable in silent settings. Users who prioritise a quieter mouse experience may prefer the MX Master 3S.

Which should you buy?

If you're seeking a premium mouse that enhances productivity with advanced features and extensive customisation, the Logitech MX Master 3S is the clear winner at £68.99. Its ergonomic design, high precision, and seamless connectivity make it a top choice for professionals. However, if you're looking for an affordable and straightforward solution for basic tasks, the Logitech M171 at £13.99 offers reliable performance and excellent battery life without the frills. Ultimately, your choice should reflect your specific needs and budget considerations.