Thermalright ASF Black V2 AM5 CPU Holder vs Noctua NM-AM5/4-MP83 chromax.black

Overview of the Thermalright ASF Black V2 AM5 CPU Holder and Noctua NM-AM5/4-MP83 chromax.black

The Thermalright ASF Black V2 AM5 CPU Holder is priced at £15.04, while the Noctua NM-AM5/4-MP83 chromax.black is significantly more affordable at £8.95. Both products aim to enhance CPU stability but target slightly different needs within the same market segment.

The Thermalright ASF Black V2 offers a dedicated solution specifically designed for the AM5 socket, providing an anti-bending corrector that supports the weight of the CPU cooler. In contrast, the Noctua NM-AM5/4-MP83 is an upgrade kit allowing compatibility for various Noctua coolers on AMD’s AM5 and AM4 sockets. The choice between these two products largely depends on the specific needs of your CPU setup and the coolers you intend to use.

Design and Build Quality

The Thermalright ASF Black V2 boasts an all-aluminium alloy construction with a black anodised finish, ensuring both durability and aesthetic appeal. Its precise workmanship and rounded perimeter are designed to prevent scratching, adding to its longevity. The dimensions are compact, measuring 70mm in length, 54mm in width, and 6mm in height, which allows for easy integration into tight spaces within a PC case.

On the other hand, the Noctua NM-AM5/4-MP83 features an all-black design with thumb screws that align with Noctua’s chromax.black line of heatsinks. This mounting upgrade kit is tailored specifically for Noctua CPU coolers with an 83mm mounting pitch. While it does not have the same solid construction as the Thermalright holder, its design effectively utilises the motherboard’s stock AMD backplate, making installation straightforward.

Compatibility

The Thermalright ASF Black V2 is exclusively designed for AMD’s AM5 CPU sockets, meaning it will not work with any other socket types. This direct compatibility ensures that it fits perfectly and reduces the risk of CPU bending during the installation of heavier coolers. It is specifically geared towards motherboards with the X670 and B650 chipsets.

In contrast, the Noctua NM-AM5/4-MP83 is versatile in its compatibility, enabling the installation of Noctua coolers on both AM5 and AM4 sockets, including Ryzen 5, Ryzen 7, and Ryzen 9 processors. This broader compatibility makes it a more flexible option for users who may want to switch between different CPU models in the future.

Installation Process

Installation of the Thermalright ASF Black V2 is designed to be user-friendly, facilitated by the inclusion of an L-shaped screwdriver. Following the provided instructions or an installation video, users can complete the installation in one step. Its design minimizes wear on the CPU cover, which is an important consideration for long-term use.

Conversely, the Noctua NM-AM5/4-MP83 is praised for its outstanding reliability and optimal contact pressure. The installation process is straightforward, leveraging the motherboard’s existing backplate for a hassle-free setup. This ease of installation is a key selling point, especially for users who may not have extensive experience with PC builds.

Performance and Stability

The Thermalright ASF Black V2 is specifically engineered to prevent CPU bending, which can occur when heavy coolers are installed. Its dedicated CPU slot and insulated foot pad reduce capacitance issues that could arise from thermal conductive materials contacting the CPU. This design focuses on maintaining stability, which is crucial for high-performance gaming or intensive computing tasks.

The Noctua NM-AM5/4-MP83 also offers reliable performance by ensuring optimal contact pressure between the cooler and the CPU. While it does not explicitly mention anti-bending features, the compatibility with Noctua coolers, known for their efficiency, suggests that it will perform well under standard operating conditions. Thus, while both products aim for stability, the Thermalright has a more focused approach in this regard.

Price and Value

With the Thermalright ASF Black V2 priced at £15.04, it positions itself as a premium product with dedicated features for AM5 users. The added benefits of preventing CPU bending and providing a bespoke fit could justify the higher price for those building high-end systems.

In contrast, the Noctua NM-AM5/4-MP83 is more budget-friendly at £8.95. This lower price point makes it an attractive option for those who already own compatible Noctua coolers and are looking for a cost-effective upgrade. The value here lies in its versatility and ease of installation, appealing to a broader audience.

User Feedback and Brand Reputation

Thermalright is known for its high-quality cooling solutions, and the ASF Black V2 continues this tradition with its premium build quality and targeted features. Users have praised its effectiveness in preventing CPU damage during heavy use, which is a significant concern for many builders.

Noctua, on the other hand, has built a strong reputation for reliability and performance in the cooling market. The NM-AM5/4-MP83 is well-regarded for its straightforward installation and excellent compatibility with a range of products. Its chromax.black aesthetics are also a plus for users looking to maintain a cohesive look in their builds.

Which should you buy?

Choosing between the Thermalright ASF Black V2 and the Noctua NM-AM5/4-MP83 ultimately depends on your specific needs. If you require a dedicated solution that focuses on preventing CPU bending and fits exclusively with AM5 sockets, the Thermalright holder is the way to go. However, if you are looking for a versatile, cost-effective mounting solution that works with Noctua coolers across both AM4 and AM5 sockets, then the Noctua NM-AM5/4-MP83 is a smart choice. Consider your CPU cooler compatibility, installation preferences, and budget to make the best decision.