BENOISON vs Lightdow

Overview of the 85mm f1.8 Portrait Lens and Lightdow Wide Angle + Macro Lens

The 85mm f1.8 Portrait Lens is a dedicated manual-focus lens for Nikon cameras, while the Lightdow Wide Angle + Macro Lens is an attachment designed for Canon cameras. Each lens serves distinct purposes and caters to different photography styles, making them suitable for varying needs. The 85mm lens is priced at $96.22, significantly higher than the Lightdow lens, which costs $25.59. This price difference of about 274% reflects the specialized nature of the 85mm lens compared to the more versatile but less specialized Lightdow attachment.

Image Quality and Performance

In terms of image quality, the 85mm f1.8 Portrait Lens excels with its large F1.8 aperture, which produces stunning background bokeh and enhances shallow depth-of-field effects. This makes it ideal for portrait and street photography, where capturing sharp subjects against blurred backgrounds is crucial. The Lightdow Wide Angle + Macro Lens, on the other hand, offers a 0.43x magnification and is designed to enhance the versatility of existing lenses by enabling wide-angle and macro photography. While the Lightdow lens increases adaptability, it does not match the optical performance of the dedicated 85mm f1.8 lens, which is crafted specifically for portraiture.

Compatibility and Use Cases

The 85mm f1.8 Portrait Lens is compatible with a wide range of Nikon DSLR cameras, including models like D3500, D850, and D7500. This specialization allows photographers to take full advantage of the lens's capabilities. Conversely, the Lightdow Wide Angle + Macro Lens is designed to fit various Canon cameras and can be used with multiple lens types, providing a broader range of applications. However, users must verify the lens thread size before ordering, which could complicate its use for some photographers. The 85mm lens, while limited to Nikon cameras, offers a clear advantage in dedicated use cases.

Focus and Exposure Control

The 85mm f1.8 Portrait Lens operates entirely in manual mode, requiring photographers to adjust focus and exposure settings themselves. This can be a drawback for those accustomed to autofocus systems, but it also allows for greater creative control. The manual focus mechanism is emphasized, providing a tactile experience for users. In contrast, the Lightdow Wide Angle + Macro Lens attaches to existing lenses, which may still utilize autofocus features, making it easier for users who prefer more automated shooting. However, the reliance on other lenses limits the Lightdow's standalone performance compared to the dedicated function of the 85mm lens.

Build Quality and Design

The 85mm f1.8 Portrait Lens is designed specifically for portrait work, with a solid build that reflects its specialized purpose. The manual focus design can be perceived as more robust, catering to photographers who prioritize image quality and lens performance. The Lightdow Wide Angle + Macro Lens, while useful, is an attachment that may not offer the same level of durability and optical quality as a dedicated lens. Its design allows for quick attachment and detachment, which enhances convenience but may sacrifice some sturdiness compared to the 85mm lens.

Price Point Considerations

The price of the 85mm f1.8 Portrait Lens at $96.22 positions it as a premium option, reflecting its specialized design and superior optical performance. In comparison, the Lightdow Wide Angle + Macro Lens is significantly more affordable at $25.59. This price difference of about $70.63 may appeal to budget-conscious photographers or those just starting out, but it also indicates the disparity in purpose and quality between the two lenses. While the Lightdow lens offers versatility at a lower price, the investment in the 85mm lens may be justified for serious portrait photographers.

User Experience and Learning Curve

Using the 85mm f1.8 Portrait Lens requires a degree of familiarity with manual focus and exposure settings, which might present a learning curve for beginners. However, this manual operation can also enhance the photographer's skill set over time. The Lightdow Wide Angle + Macro Lens is more user-friendly, especially for those who prefer the convenience of autofocus and quick attachment. This ease of use makes it a better choice for casual photographers or those looking for a simple way to expand their creative options without a steep learning curve.

Which should you buy?

Ultimately, the choice between the 85mm f1.8 Portrait Lens and the Lightdow Wide Angle + Macro Lens depends on your photography needs and budget. If you're a serious portrait photographer using a Nikon camera, the 85mm lens offers unparalleled image quality and creative control, making it worth the higher price. However, if you’re a Canon user looking for versatility and affordability, the Lightdow lens attachment provides a practical solution for enhancing your photography without breaking the bank. Each lens has its merits, and the decision should align with your specific photographic goals.