BENOISON vs Meike

Introduction

When comparing the 85mm f1.8 Portrait Lens - F Lens for Nikon and the Meike 50mm F1.8 Auto Focus STM Stepping Motor lens, it's essential to evaluate their unique features and compatibility. The former is a manual focus lens priced at $96.22, while the latter offers autofocus capabilities at $159.99. Both lenses cater to photographers looking to capture stunning portraits, but their functionalities and intended users vary significantly.

Design and Build Quality

The 85mm f1.8 Portrait Lens has a straightforward design focused on manual operation. As a manual focus lens, users must adjust the focus ring themselves, which might appeal to those who prefer a hands-on approach. This lens is compatible with numerous Nikon DSLR models, maintaining a classic feel that many photographers appreciate. On the other hand, the Meike 50mm F1.8 features a more modern design with a dedicated AF/MF focus mode switch, allowing for quick transitions between autofocus and manual focus. Its build quality is enhanced by low-dispersion glass that helps reduce chromatic aberration, ensuring clearer images.

Compatibility

The 85mm f1.8 Portrait Lens is compatible with a wide range of Nikon DSLR cameras, including the D3500, D850, and D7500, among others. It is not compatible with Nikon's Z-series mirrorless cameras, which limits its versatility for users transitioning to newer camera systems. Conversely, the Meike 50mm F1.8 is designed specifically for Nikon Z mount cameras, including models like the Z50 and Z7. This makes it an excellent choice for users who have upgraded to Nikon's mirrorless technology, as it fully supports electronic aperture adjustment and EXIF information transmission.

Autofocus vs. Manual Focus

A significant difference between these two lenses is their focusing mechanism. The 85mm f1.8 Portrait Lens is entirely manual, which requires the photographer to have a keen eye for detail and a steady hand to achieve sharp focus. This might deter beginners but appeals to seasoned photographers who enjoy the creative control manual focusing provides. In contrast, the Meike 50mm F1.8 offers autofocus functionality, which is particularly beneficial for those shooting dynamic subjects or working in fast-paced environments. The autofocus feature allows for quicker adjustments, making it easier to capture spontaneous moments without missing the shot.

Aperture and Image Quality

Both lenses feature a maximum aperture of f1.8, which is excellent for low-light photography and creating a shallow depth of field. The 85mm f1.8 Portrait Lens excels at producing beautiful background bokeh, ideal for portrait photography with a natural perspective. However, because it is a manual focus lens, achieving the desired focus may require extra effort. The Meike 50mm F1.8 also produces pleasing bokeh thanks to its nine aperture blades, while its autofocus system ensures that subjects remain sharp even in challenging lighting conditions. This can be particularly advantageous in portrait and street photography scenarios.

Price Comparison

The 85mm f1.8 Portrait Lens is priced at $96.22, which is about 40% cheaper than the Meike 50mm F1.8, retailing at $159.99. This substantial price difference may influence the decision for budget-conscious photographers or those just starting. While the 85mm lens may lack modern features, its lower price point makes it accessible for those who want to explore portrait photography without a significant financial commitment. Conversely, the Meike lens, while more expensive, offers advanced features that may justify the investment for users seeking enhanced functionality and compatibility with newer camera systems.

Use Cases

The 85mm f1.8 Portrait Lens is particularly well-suited for portrait photography, allowing for half-body and full-body shots with stunning detail. Its design is also favorable for street photography, where a natural perspective is desired. However, the manual focus feature may pose challenges in fast-paced shooting situations. In contrast, the Meike 50mm F1.8 is versatile, excelling in various photography styles, including portraits, street photography, architecture, and landscapes. Its autofocus capability makes it suitable for a broader range of scenarios, allowing photographers to adapt quickly to changing environments.

User Experience

Using the 85mm f1.8 Portrait Lens requires a more hands-on approach, making it essential for photographers to be comfortable with manual focus techniques. Users will appreciate the tactile experience and the control it offers, but beginners might find it challenging. The lens also may present an initial error message regarding "Lens not attached," which can be resolved by switching the camera to manual mode. On the other hand, the Meike 50mm F1.8 provides a more user-friendly experience with its autofocus feature and dedicated focus mode switch. This lens is designed for ease of use, particularly for those who may not have extensive experience with manual focusing.

Which should you buy?

Choosing between the 85mm f1.8 Portrait Lens and the Meike 50mm F1.8 depends on your photography style and needs. If you are a budget-conscious photographer who prefers manual control and is using a Nikon DSLR, the 85mm lens offers excellent value for money. However, if you have transitioned to Nikon's Z-series mirrorless system and desire a more modern lens with autofocus capabilities, the Meike 50mm F1.8 would be a superior choice. Ultimately, each lens serves different users well, so consider your specific requirements before making a decision.