Behringer BC1200 Professional 7-Piece Drum vs Phenyx Pro PDM34 Snare Drum Mic, Cardioid Dynamic

Overview of the Behringer BC1200 and Phenyx Pro PDM34

The Behringer BC1200 is a comprehensive 7-piece drum microphone set, while the Phenyx Pro PDM34 is a single cardioid dynamic microphone designed specifically for snare drums. The BC1200 is priced at $129.00, making it a more extensive investment, while the PDM34 is available for $37.99, which is about 70% cheaper. This price difference reflects the intended use and functionality of each product, with the BC1200 catering to a broader range of applications.

Target Audience

The Behringer BC1200 is ideal for musicians, sound engineers, and recording studios that need a versatile microphone setup for various drum kits and live performances. With its seven microphones tailored for different parts of a drum set, it suits those who want a complete solution. In contrast, the Phenyx Pro PDM34 targets drummers looking for a dedicated snare mic. Its focused design and cardioid pick-up pattern make it suitable for capturing the snare's distinct sound, appealing to performers and hobbyists alike.

Features and Functionality

The Behringer BC1200 includes a large diaphragm dynamic microphone for bass drums, four dynamic microphones for snare and toms, and two condenser microphones for overhead stereo imaging. This diverse set-up allows for capturing the full nuance of a drum kit. On the other hand, the Phenyx Pro PDM34 features a robust build quality with a cardioid pattern that effectively reduces ambient noise. It can handle extreme sound pressure levels over 160dB, making it a reliable choice for high-energy performances.

Build Quality

When it comes to build quality, the Behringer BC1200 offers a professional-grade set of microphones designed for both studio and live applications. While specific materials aren't mentioned, the set's professional intent suggests durability. The Phenyx Pro PDM34 stands out with its sleek design and sturdy metal housing, which adds to its longevity. Its integral stand mount and clip-on clamp provide flexibility in positioning, making it user-friendly during live performances.

Portability

The Behringer BC1200, consisting of seven microphones, may be bulkier and less portable compared to the single PDM34 mic. Each component of the BC1200 requires careful handling and transportation. Conversely, the PDM34 is compact and comes with a microphone bag, making it easier to transport and set up for quick snare drum captures on the go. For musicians who prioritize portability, the PDM34 is a more convenient option.

Price Comparison

The Behringer BC1200 is priced at $129.00, while the Phenyx Pro PDM34 is offered at $37.99. This represents a significant price difference, with the BC1200 being about 70% more expensive. However, given the BC1200's seven microphones versus the single unit of the PDM34, the pricing can be justified based on the features offered. Musicians needing a complete drum mic set might find the investment worthwhile, while those focused solely on snare performance may prefer the budget-friendly PDM34.

Sales Ranking and Popularity

In terms of market performance, the Behringer BC1200 holds a better sales rank at 6408, indicating a more substantial presence and popularity among consumers. Meanwhile, the Phenyx Pro PDM34 sits at a sales rank of 21850, suggesting it is less frequently purchased. This could indicate a preference for more comprehensive solutions like the BC1200 among serious drummers and sound professionals, while the PDM34 might attract those seeking a specific, cost-effective microphone.

Which should you buy?

Choosing between the Behringer BC1200 and the Phenyx Pro PDM34 largely depends on your specific needs. If you require a full drum microphone set for various applications, the Behringer BC1200 offers unmatched versatility and quality, justifying its higher price. However, if you're primarily a drummer looking for a reliable snare mic that won’t break the bank, the Phenyx Pro PDM34 is an excellent choice at a significantly lower price point. Ultimately, your decision should be guided by whether you need a comprehensive solution or a focused, economical option.