Behringer BC1200 Professional 7-Piece Drum vs Shure SM57 Dynamic Microphone – Wired Cardioid XLR

Overview of the Behringer BC1200 and Shure SM57

When comparing the Behringer BC1200 and the Shure SM57, it’s clear that both microphones serve distinct purposes and are tailored for different users. The Behringer BC1200, priced at $129.00, is a comprehensive drum microphone set designed for capturing the nuances of a full drum kit. In contrast, the Shure SM57, retailing at $98.00, is a versatile dynamic microphone renowned for its clarity across various instruments, particularly in live and studio settings. The price difference of about 17% positions the Shure SM57 as the more budget-friendly option.

Design and Build Quality

Both the Behringer BC1200 and the Shure SM57 are built with functionality in mind, yet they differ significantly in design. The Behringer BC1200 is a set comprising seven microphones, including a large diaphragm dynamic microphone designed specifically for bass drums, along with four dynamic microphones for snare and toms, and two condenser microphones for overhead stereo imaging. This comprehensive setup is ideal for drummers looking for a complete solution. Conversely, the Shure SM57 is a single microphone known for its rugged construction, capable of handling high sound pressure levels and frequent transportation, making it a reliable choice for both studio and live applications.

Sound Quality

Sound quality is a critical aspect when selecting a microphone, and both the Behringer BC1200 and the Shure SM57 deliver impressive performance. The Behringer BC1200 is specifically tuned to capture the full range of a drum kit, ensuring that each nuance is faithfully reproduced. Its large diaphragm microphone is particularly effective for low frequencies, while the dynamic and condenser mics provide clarity and depth. On the other hand, the Shure SM57 is celebrated for its contoured frequency response that enhances attack and detail, making it ideal for instruments like snare drums and brass. It excels in reducing background noise due to its cardioid pickup pattern, allowing musicians to focus on their sound sources.

Versatility

In terms of versatility, the Shure SM57 stands out as a true all-rounder. It is highly adaptable, suitable for miking guitar amplifiers, snare drums, percussion, and even brass instruments, making it a staple in both live and studio environments. Its ability to maintain clear, professional-quality sound across numerous applications is a key feature that has earned it a bestseller rank of 279. The Behringer BC1200, while versatile for drummers, is more specialized. It is designed to capture the full spectrum of a drum kit and may not perform as well with other instruments outside of this context.

Ease of Use

User-friendliness is an essential consideration, especially for beginners. The Behringer BC1200 comes as a complete set, simplifying the process for users who may not know which microphones to choose for different drum elements. This package is ideal for users who want a straightforward solution for live performances or studio recordings. Conversely, the Shure SM57, being a single microphone, offers straightforward operation but requires users to understand its positioning and application across various instruments. Its durability and reliability make it easy to use, even in challenging environments.

Price and Value

The price points of these microphones reflect their intended use and target audience. The Behringer BC1200 offers great value for those specifically looking for a drum microphone set at $129.00. It provides a comprehensive package that includes multiple microphones tailored for different parts of a drum kit. In contrast, the Shure SM57, priced at $98.00, offers considerable savings of about $31.00 while delivering exceptional sound quality and versatility. For musicians or engineers working with a range of instruments, the Shure SM57 may present a better value proposition.

Target Audience

The target audience for each microphone varies significantly. The Behringer BC1200 is aimed at drummers and sound engineers looking for a complete solution for miking a full drum kit. Its seven-piece set caters specifically to those needs, making it a perfect fit for live performances and studio recordings focused on drums. On the other hand, the Shure SM57 appeals to a broader audience, including guitarists, percussionists, and sound engineers who require a reliable and versatile microphone for a variety of applications. Its reputation as a trusted tool in both live and studio settings makes it a favorite among professionals across different musical genres.

Which should you buy?

Deciding between the Behringer BC1200 and the Shure SM57 ultimately depends on your specific needs. If you are a drummer seeking a specialized microphone set to capture the intricacies of your kit, the Behringer BC1200 at $129.00 is an excellent choice. However, if versatility, durability, and a budget-friendly option are your priorities, then the Shure SM57 at $98.00 stands out as the better investment, especially for those working across various instruments and environments.