Behringer BC1200 Professional 7-piece Drum Microphone Set vs Phenyx Pro PDM34 Snare Drum Mic, Cardioid Dynamic

Overview of the Products

The Behringer BC1200 Professional 7-piece Drum Microphone Set offers a full drum mic setup at a competitive price, while the Phenyx Pro PDM34 Snare Drum Mic is a specialized microphone designed for snare drums. At $129.00, the Behringer set provides seven mics, including a kick mic, four tom/snare mics, and two cymbal mics. In contrast, the Phenyx Pro is priced at $37.99 and focuses solely on snare drum performance. This price difference shows that the Behringer set is more versatile, offering an entire kit for about 70% more than the single snare mic from Phenyx Pro.

Sound Quality

When it comes to sound quality, both microphones aim to deliver professional results but in different contexts. The Behringer BC1200 is crafted to provide studio-quality recordings with its KM1200 kick mic and TM1200 mics, which capture the nuanced sounds of drums with clarity. The Phenyx Pro PDM34, featuring a cardioid polar pattern, is tailored for snare drums, effectively picking up sound while minimizing ambient noise. This mic handles extreme sound pressure levels over 160dB without distortion, making it ideal for loud drumming sessions. Each microphone shines in its intended use, but the Behringer set offers a broader range of sound-capturing options.

Build Quality

The build quality of each product reflects its intended use and pricing. The Behringer BC1200 comes with sturdy construction and includes clamps and windscreens, ensuring durability during live performances and recording sessions. It also features a durable case for transport, which adds to its practicality. On the other hand, the Phenyx Pro PDM34 boasts a sleek design with robust metal housing and an integral stand mount, emphasizing its reliability for snare drum applications. While the Phenyx Pro is well-built for a single mic, the comprehensive nature of the Behringer set provides more value in terms of construction and included accessories.

Versatility

Versatility is where the Behringer BC1200 truly excels. With seven microphones designed for different parts of a drum kit, it caters to a variety of recording situations, making it an ideal choice for drummers who want a complete setup. The set includes dedicated mics for kick, snare, toms, and overheads, allowing for a full capture of the drum sound. In contrast, the Phenyx Pro PDM34 is specifically optimized for snare drums, limiting its versatility. While it excels in its niche, it does not provide the same range of options as the Behringer set, which is a key consideration for those looking to record an entire drum kit.

Pricing and Value

In terms of pricing, the Behringer BC1200 is priced at $129.00, while the Phenyx Pro PDM34 retails for $37.99. The Behringer set is approximately 70% higher in price but offers a complete package of seven microphones. Considering the number of microphones included, the Behringer set provides more value for those needing an extensive setup. The Phenyx Pro, although cheaper, serves a more limited purpose, making it a less cost-effective option for those who need more than just a snare mic. The decision ultimately depends on whether you require a full kit or a single mic.

Ease of Use

Both microphones are designed with user-friendly features, but they cater to different user experiences. The Behringer BC1200 includes multiple mics, which may require more setup time but ultimately provides a comprehensive solution for capturing drum sounds. Each mic comes with clamps and accessories to facilitate easy positioning. In contrast, the Phenyx Pro PDM34 is designed for simplicity, featuring a clip-on microphone clamp and an integral stand mount that make it easy to set up and adjust during performances. For quick and straightforward use, especially in live settings, the Phenyx Pro may have the upper hand.

Brand Reputation

Behringer and Phenyx Pro both have established reputations in the audio equipment market. Behringer is known for providing quality products at competitive prices, making it a popular choice among budget-conscious musicians. With a sales rank of 27,569, the BC1200 demonstrates a solid presence in the market. Phenyx Pro, while also reputable, has a slightly better sales rank at 21,850, which may indicate a growing preference for its products. Both brands are trusted by users, but Behringer's more extensive offering may appeal to those looking for a reliable, all-in-one solution.

Which should you buy?

Deciding between the Behringer BC1200 Professional 7-piece Drum Microphone Set and the Phenyx Pro PDM34 Snare Drum Mic depends on your specific needs. If you require a complete setup for recording an entire drum kit, the Behringer set is the clear choice, offering seven microphones for $129.00. However, if your focus is solely on snare drum performance and you appreciate the simplicity and lower price point of $37.99, the Phenyx Pro is a solid option. Ultimately, your decision should be guided by whether you need versatility and a full set or a focused, high-quality mic for snare drums.