Behringer BC1200 Professional 7-piece Drum Microphone Set vs Shure PGA57 Dynamic Microphone

Overview of the Products

In this comparison, we will evaluate the Behringer BC1200 Professional 7-piece Drum Microphone Set and the Shure PGA57 Dynamic Microphone. The Behringer set is priced at $129.00, while the Shure microphone retails for $71.00, making it about 45% cheaper than the Behringer option. Both products cater to different needs, with the Behringer set designed specifically for drummers and the Shure microphone targeting instrumentalists and drum performers.

Design and Build Quality

The Behringer BC1200 set comprises seven microphones, including a kick mic, four tom/snare mics, and two cymbal mics, all housed in a sturdy case for easy transport. This complete drum mic set is built for durability and convenience, featuring clamps and windscreens. On the other hand, the Shure PGA57 has a single dynamic microphone with a tailored cartridge design for clear sound reproduction, featuring a black metallic finish that enhances its professional appearance. While the Behringer set offers multiple mics, the Shure microphone is crafted for versatility in various performance settings.

Sound Quality

When it comes to sound quality, the Behringer BC1200 provides a full and rich sound, particularly with its KM1200 kick mic that delivers the deep bass tones required in modern music. The included TM1200 mics for snare and toms capture sound with clarity, while the CM1200 overhead mics handle cymbals effectively. Conversely, the Shure PGA57 is designed with a cardioid polar pattern, ensuring that it captures audio from the source while minimizing background noise. Both microphones excel in their respective domains, but the Behringer set offers a more extensive sonic range due to its multi-mic setup.

Versatility

The Behringer BC1200 is specifically tailored for capturing drum sounds, making it ideal for drummers and bands focusing on percussion-heavy music. It comes with a complete set of mics designed to cover various aspects of a drum kit. In contrast, the Shure PGA57 is a versatile instrument microphone suitable not only for drums but also for other amplified instruments. Its design allows it to adapt to different performance environments, making it a great all-around microphone for various applications. While the Behringer is specialized, the Shure offers broader usability.

Accessories Included

In terms of included accessories, the Behringer BC1200 comes with clamps and windscreens for all microphones, ensuring a ready-to-use setup right out of the box. The sturdy case provides added protection and ease of transport. The Shure PGA57 includes a swivel adapter for mounting on a microphone stand and a carrying pouch, though it does not come with an XLR cable unless specifically purchased with one. This means that while the Behringer set offers comprehensive accessories for a drum setup, the Shure microphone requires additional purchases for full functionality.

Price Comparison

The Behringer BC1200 is priced at $129.00, while the Shure PGA57 is available for $71.00, making the Behringer set about 81% more expensive. This significant price difference reflects the Behringer's offering of multiple microphones and accessories, which contributes to its higher cost. For those on a tight budget or who need just a single microphone for performances or recordings, the Shure PGA57 presents a more economical choice without sacrificing sound quality.

Use Case Scenarios

The Behringer BC1200 is ideal for bands and studios focused on producing high-quality drum recordings, providing all the necessary tools to capture every nuance of a drum kit. Its seven-piece setup is beneficial for larger ensembles or professional recording sessions. In contrast, the Shure PGA57 is better suited for solo performers or smaller setups where versatility is key. Its dynamic design allows it to handle both amplified and acoustic instruments effectively, making it a practical choice for various musical settings.

Popularity and Sales Rank

In terms of popularity, the Behringer BC1200 holds a sales rank of 27,569, while the Shure PGA57 enjoys a better sales rank of 20,657. This indicates that the Shure microphone is more frequently purchased, possibly due to its lower price point and versatility. The Behringer set, while popular among specific users, may not appeal to as wide an audience, given its focused application for drummers.

Which should you buy?

Ultimately, the choice between the Behringer BC1200 and the Shure PGA57 depends on your specific needs. If you are a drummer or part of a band looking for a comprehensive drum mic solution, the Behringer BC1200 is well worth the investment for its quality and versatility in capturing a full drum kit. However, if you are looking for a single, versatile microphone that can perform well across various instruments and settings, the Shure PGA57 is an excellent choice, especially considering its lower price point.