Behringer BC1200 Professional 7-piece Drum Microphone Set vs Shure SM57 & SM58 Microphone Set

Overview of the Behringer BC1200 and Shure SM57 & SM58

The Behringer BC1200 Professional 7-piece Drum Microphone Set is priced at $129.00, while the Shure SM57 & SM58 Microphone Set costs $196.00, making the Behringer option about 34% cheaper. This considerable price difference sets the stage for a detailed comparison of their features and intended uses.

Intended Use and Versatility

The Behringer BC1200 is designed specifically for drummers, offering a complete set of seven microphones tailored for capturing various drum components. In contrast, the Shure SM57 & SM58 set is intended for both instruments and vocals, showcasing its versatility across different performance contexts. The inclusion of a dynamic cardioid vocal microphone in the Shure set makes it suitable for live performances and studio recordings alike.

Features and Accessories

The Behringer BC1200 comes with seven pieces: one kick mic, four tom/snare mics, and two cymbal mics, along with clamps and windscreens, which enhance its usability in various settings. Additionally, it includes a sturdy case for easy storage and transport. On the other hand, the Shure set features two renowned microphones, the SM57, typically used for instruments, and the SM58, designed for vocals. While the Behringer set provides more mics, the Shure set's reputation for quality sound cannot be overlooked.

Sound Quality

Sound quality is crucial for any microphone set. The Behringer BC1200 offers a kick mic that delivers a "fat and full bass drum sound," essential for capturing dynamic drum performances. The four tom/snare mics are designed to beautifully capture snare and tom sounds, while the overhead mics effectively handle cymbals. In comparison, the Shure microphones are celebrated for their crisp sound and versatile performance, particularly in live settings. The SM58 is often regarded as the industry standard for vocal performance, while the SM57 excels in instrument mic'ing.

Build Quality and Durability

The Behringer BC1200 includes a sturdy case that allows for safe stowing of all components, making it a practical choice for musicians on the go. The microphones themselves are built to withstand the rigors of live performances, ensuring longevity. The Shure microphones are also known for their robust build quality, especially the SM58, which is designed to handle rough treatment on stage. Both sets cater to durability but target different use cases, with the Behringer set focusing on a complete drum setup and Shure emphasizing individual performance reliability.

Price and Value

At $129.00, the Behringer BC1200 is a compelling option for drummers looking for a full microphone setup without breaking the bank. This price is about $67 less than the Shure SM57 & SM58 set, which costs $196. The Behringer set has a sales rank of 27,569, indicating a decent level of popularity, while the Shure set ranks slightly higher at 21,805, reflecting its established reputation in the market. The value proposition of the Behringer set is compelling for those needing multiple mics for drums, while the Shure set offers a premium sound experience that justifies its higher price.

Target Audience

The Behringer BC1200 targets drummers, particularly those who require a comprehensive mic setup for recording or live performances. It’s ideal for musicians who want to capture the entire drum kit without needing to purchase individual mics separately. In contrast, the Shure SM57 & SM58 set caters to a broader audience, including vocalists and instrumentalists, making it a versatile choice for various musical applications. This broad appeal may justify the higher price tag for many users.

Which should you buy?

In conclusion, the choice between the Behringer BC1200 Professional 7-piece Drum Microphone Set and the Shure SM57 & SM58 Microphone Set largely depends on your specific needs. If you are a drummer looking for an economical and complete mic solution, the Behringer BC1200, priced at $129.00, is the clear winner due to its comprehensive set of microphones tailored for drums. However, if you are looking for a versatile solution that performs well for both vocals and instruments, the Shure set, despite its higher price of $196.00, offers unmatched sound quality and durability that many professionals trust.