BLACK+DECKER 20V MAX Pole Hedge Trimmer Cordless vs CRAFTSMAN CMCPHT818B V20* Cordless Pole Hedge

Overview of the BLACK+DECKER and CRAFTSMAN Hedge Trimmers

The BLACK+DECKER 20V MAX Pole Hedge Trimmer is priced at $129.00, making it about 17% cheaper than the CRAFTSMAN CMCPHT818B, which costs $139.99. Both models are designed for cutting hedges and shrubs up to 11 feet high, but they offer different features and functionalities that cater to various user needs.

Design and Build Quality

The BLACK+DECKER hedge trimmer features a lightweight design at only 7.7 lbs, allowing for ease of use during extended periods. It has an adjustable length that extends up to 11 feet, facilitating access to taller plants. In contrast, the CRAFTSMAN model is built with an emphasis on comfort, featuring a padded grip for better handling. However, it is important to note that the CRAFTSMAN is a "tool only" model, which means the battery and charger are sold separately, potentially increasing the overall cost for users who do not already own compatible batteries.

Cutting Performance

When comparing cutting capabilities, the BLACK+DECKER trimmer offers an 18-inch dual-action blade that reduces vibration and can cut branches up to 7/16 inches thick. The CRAFTSMAN’s dual-action blades are also 18 inches long but can handle thicker branches, cutting up to 3/4 inches. This difference in cutting ability may influence the choice for users who routinely work with thicker growth.

Versatility and Reach

Both hedge trimmers allow for an impressive reach of up to 11 feet, making them suitable for various yard tasks. The BLACK+DECKER model has a 180-degree pivoting head that adjusts to five different positions, providing flexibility for different cutting angles. The CRAFTSMAN also features a pivoting head with five positions. However, while both models excel in reach and versatility, the BLACK+DECKER’s included battery and charger add to its overall value as a complete package.

User Comfort

User comfort is a significant factor in choosing a hedge trimmer. The BLACK+DECKER trimmer incorporates a soft-grip handle for extended use, which enhances control during operation. The CRAFTSMAN model, while featuring a padded grip, does not provide the same level of comprehensive comfort features. BLACK+DECKER's design may be more beneficial for users engaging in long trimming sessions, making it a more ergonomic choice.

Storage and Maintenance

Storage convenience is an essential consideration for many users. The CRAFTSMAN hedge trimmer includes an integrated VERSATRACK hook for easy hanging, which is a practical feature if you already own the VERSATRACK system. The BLACK+DECKER model does not specifically mention a storage feature but may be easily stored due to its lightweight and compact design. Both products require regular maintenance, but the ease of storage could be a deciding factor for those with limited space.

Battery Life and Charging

The BLACK+DECKER hedge trimmer comes with a 20V MAX lithium-ion battery, which holds a charge for up to 18 months, ensuring that it’s ready to use when needed. Conversely, the CRAFTSMAN model is marketed as "tool only," meaning the battery and charger must be purchased separately. This can lead to additional costs and inconvenience for users who do not already own compatible batteries. The superior battery life of the BLACK+DECKER could provide a more user-friendly experience, especially for those who require frequent use.

Which should you buy?

The decision between the BLACK+DECKER 20V MAX Pole Hedge Trimmer and the CRAFTSMAN CMCPHT818B boils down to specific user needs. The BLACK+DECKER model is about 17% cheaper, includes a battery and charger, and offers a lightweight design with excellent reach and cutting performance. On the other hand, the CRAFTSMAN may appeal to those who need to tackle thicker branches and prefer to purchase tools separately. If you value a complete package with long battery life and user comfort, the BLACK+DECKER is the superior choice. However, if you already have the CRAFTSMAN battery system and need a robust tool for tougher cuts, the CRAFTSMAN might be worth considering.