BLACK+DECKER Over the Range Microwave vs FRIGIDAIRE EMW733BLACKAMZ 0.7 Cu. Ft.

Design and build quality

The BLACK+DECKER Over the Range Microwave is engineered for installation above a cooking range, featuring a stainless steel exterior that integrates with kitchen cabinetry. Its dimensions are substantial, measuring 15.4 inches in depth, 29.9 inches in width, and 16.4 inches in height. This design includes an integrated light to offer focused lighting while cooking on the stove below. In contrast, the Frigidaire model is designed as a countertop unit, prioritizing a smaller footprint for placement on flat surfaces. It features a digital control panel and a large display that provides clear viewing of meal progress. The build quality of the BLACK+DECKER unit reflects its dual purpose as both a cooking appliance and a ventilation hood, whereas the Frigidaire focuses on standalone convenience.

Capacity and interior space

Capacity is a major differentiator between these two appliances. The BLACK+DECKER model offers a spacious interior with 1.7 cubic feet of capacity, making it suitable for family-sized meals and larger cookware. It includes a 12.4-inch turntable to ensure even heating of large plates. The Frigidaire unit provides 0.7 cubic feet of space, which is categorized as compact. This smaller capacity is adequate for single servings, beverages, or reheating snacks but may struggle with larger dinner plates. Users requiring significant interior volume for casseroles or multiple items will find the BLACK+DECKER option much more versatile for daily cooking adventures.

Performance and power

Cooking performance is largely dictated by power output and cooking levels. The BLACK+DECKER microwave operates with a 1000-watt output, providing strong heating capabilities for quick action cooking. It features 10 cooking levels, allowing users to adjust power from 100% down to lower settings for specific tasks. The Frigidaire model allows for altering the power level via its digital panel, though the specific wattage is not listed in the provided data. The BLACK+DECKER unit also supports multi-stage cooking, enabling users to save time by cooking with 90% microwave power for one duration and then switching to 50% power for another within a single setting. This flexibility supports more complex heating requirements.

Cooking features and modes

Both microwaves offer automated settings to simplify daily cooking. The BLACK+DECKER unit includes 6 quick menus for daily meals, including settings for Popcorn, Beverage, Melt/Soften, Reheat, and Defrost. It also features speedy cooking keys where pressing numbers 1, 2, or 3 sets the 100% power level for 1 to 3 minutes. The Frigidaire model provides six different auto cooking settings as well, covering popcorn, potato, pizza, frozen dinner, reheat, and beverage. It utilizes two different defrost timers to give full control over how food is warmed. While both offer similar counts of auto menus, the BLACK+DECKER includes specific melt and soften functions that add versatility to food preparation.

Ventilation and installation

Ventilation is a unique feature found only in the over-the-range model. The BLACK+DECKER microwave includes a 300 CFM vent fan with 2-speed strong suction. This powerful vent helps to remove fumes and odors from the cooking area, functioning as a range hood substitute. The Frigidaire countertop model does not include ventilation capabilities, as it is not designed to be mounted above a stove. Installation for the BLACK+DECKER unit requires mounting hardware and access to external venting or recirculation setups, whereas the Frigidaire unit simply requires a power outlet and counter space. This makes the Frigidaire easier to install but limits its functionality regarding air quality management.

Safety and ease of use

Safety features are explicitly highlighted in the Frigidaire product data. It includes a Child Safety Lock that prevents inadvertent usage or access, which is crucial for households with young children. The large display also helps users keep an eye on meals to ensure they cook perfectly. The BLACK+DECKER model mentions an integrated light for visibility but does not specify a child lock feature in the provided data. Ease of use is high for both, with the BLACK+DECKER offering quick number keys for express cooking and the Frigidaire offering a digital panel for setting time and stop/cancel features. The Frigidaire also allows for postponing the start, adding a layer of scheduling convenience.

Price and value

Price is the most significant advantage for the Frigidaire model. It is listed at $81.80, which is substantially lower than the BLACK+DECKER unit priced at $287.99. This price difference reflects the difference in installation complexity, capacity, and additional features like ventilation. For users on a budget or those who only need basic reheating capabilities, the Frigidaire offers excellent value. However, the BLACK+DECKER provides higher value for users who need to replace a range hood and microwave simultaneously, as it combines two appliances into one unit. The higher cost is justified by the 1000-watt power, larger capacity, and ventilation system.

Which one should you buy

Choosing between these models depends on your kitchen layout and cooking needs. If you need to replace an existing over-the-range unit or require ventilation for your stove, the BLACK+DECKER is the necessary choice. Its 1.7 cubic feet capacity and 1000-watt power make it suitable for primary cooking duties. If you have limited counter space, a tight budget, or only need a microwave for basic tasks like reheating beverages and popcorn, the Frigidaire is the practical option. Its child safety lock and low price point make it ideal for dorms, offices, or secondary kitchen spaces. Ultimately, the BLACK+DECKER wins on performance and capacity, while the Frigidaire wins on affordability and compact design.