Brother MFC-J1010DW Wireless Color vs Canon PIXMA TS4320 Wireless Color Inkjet

Design and build quality

The Brother MFC-J1010DW is designed with a focus on compact business functionality, fitting full features into a small footprint. It includes a 1.8-inch color display for navigation, which aids in controlling functions and checking status without needing a computer. The Canon PIXMA TS4320 adopts a budget-friendly design suitable for home users and hybrid workers. While specific dimensions are not provided for either unit, the Brother model emphasizes a small design despite its added fax capabilities. The Canon unit focuses on simplicity, aiming for effortless integration into home environments. Both units are built to handle standard office or home desk placements, though the Brother model may offer a more robust interface due to its included screen.

Printing capabilities and functions

Functionality is a key differentiator between these two all-in-one devices. The Brother MFC-J1010DW offers full functionality including print, copy, scan, and fax, making it a true 4-in-1 solution for small offices. This inclusion of fax capabilities sets it apart from many competitors in this price range. The Canon PIXMA TS4320 covers the essential trio of print, scan, and copy operations. It utilizes a 2-cartridge hybrid ink system designed to deliver sharp text and vivid colors for both documents and photos. While the Canon handles standard creative tasks well, the Brother model provides a more comprehensive suite of business-level features within its compact design.

Performance and speed

When evaluating raw performance, the Brother MFC-J1010DW provides specific speed metrics that cater to productivity. It is capable of printing up to 17 pages per minute in black and 9.5 pages per minute in color. These speeds are complemented by automatic two-sided printing to save time. The Canon PIXMA TS4320 emphasizes crisp and vibrant prints but does not specify pages per minute in the provided data. For users where throughput is critical, the Brother model offers verified speed capabilities. The Canon focuses on quality output through its hybrid ink system, ensuring impressive results for photos and documents even if raw speed is not explicitly quantified.

Paper handling and capacity

Paper management is where the Brother MFC-J1010DW shows significant advantage for higher volume tasks. It features a 150-sheet adjustable paper tray, which allows for less frequent refilling during busy work periods. Additionally, it includes a 20-page automatic document feeder, facilitating multi-page scanning or copying without manual intervention. The Canon PIXMA TS4320 supports diverse media up to 8.5 inches by 11 inches, with or without borders. However, specific tray capacity or ADF details are not provided in the available data. Users requiring frequent multi-page document handling will find the Brother's feeder and larger tray more conducive to sustained workflows.

Efficiency and consumables

Efficiency in printing often relates to paper usage and ink management. The Brother MFC-J1010DW supports automatic two-sided printing, which helps reduce paper consumption and time spent on manual flipping. It also works with Alexa for ink level alerts and optional automatic reordering, ensuring users do not run out of supplies unexpectedly. The Canon PIXMA TS4320 also optimizes printing with automatic 2-sided printing to reduce paper consumption. Its 2-cartridge hybrid ink system is designed for value and quality. Both models offer mechanisms to streamline consumable usage, though Brother provides a more integrated smart ink management system through voice assistant compatibility.

Software and ecosystem

Connectivity and software integration are vital for modern wireless printing. The Brother MFC-J1010DW is mobile and cloud ready, allowing users to manage printing and scanning via the Brother Mobile Connect App or connect directly to cloud services. The Canon PIXMA TS4320 offers reliable wireless connectivity with dual-band Wi-Fi, supporting both 2.4GHz and 5GHz frequencies for stable connections anywhere in the home or office. Canon emphasizes effortless setup for smartphones and computers to ensure users can start without delay. While Brother offers broader cloud integration, Canon provides potentially more stable wireless connections through dual-band support, which is beneficial in congested network environments.

Price and value

Cost is a major deciding factor for budget-conscious buyers. The Canon PIXMA TS4320 is priced at $107.00, positioning it as an affordable versatility option for home users. The Brother MFC-J1010DW is priced higher at $145.00, reflecting its additional business-level features such as fax and ADF. For users who need fax capabilities and higher paper capacity, the Brother model offers better long-term value despite the higher upfront cost. However, for basic home printing needs where fax is unnecessary, the Canon provides exceptional value. The price difference of $38.00 buys significant hardware additions in the Brother model, justifying the cost for specific professional use cases.

Which one should you buy?

Choosing between these printers depends on your specific workflow requirements. If you need a comprehensive business tool with fax capabilities, faster verified print speeds, and an automatic document feeder, the Brother MFC-J1010DW is the recommended choice. Its 150-sheet tray and smart ink management support higher volume tasks efficiently. Conversely, if you are a home user prioritizing cost savings and stable dual-band Wi-Fi connectivity, the Canon PIXMA TS4320 is the better option. It delivers quality prints and borderless media support at a lower price point. Ultimately, the Brother wins on functionality, while the Canon wins on affordability and network flexibility.