Brother MFC-L2820DW Wireless Compact Monochrome vs HP Smart Tank Plus 651 Wireless All-in-One

Price Comparison

When comparing prices, the Brother MFC-L2820DW is priced at $279.99, making it about 15% cheaper than the HP Smart Tank Plus 651, which costs $329.89. This price difference of approximately $49.90 might be significant for budget-conscious consumers. The Brother printer also maintains a competitive average price of $274.76 over the past 90 days, suggesting stable pricing, while the HP model has seen a higher average of $280.34 in the same timeframe. If your primary concern is cost, the Brother MFC-L2820DW stands out as the more economical choice.

Print Quality

Both printers offer high-quality printing, but they cater to different needs. The Brother MFC-L2820DW produces crisp black-and-white prints with a speed of up to 36 pages per minute. This makes it particularly suitable for small office environments where efficiency is key. On the other hand, the HP Smart Tank Plus 651 focuses on color printing and provides a cartridge-free experience with vibrant colors and sharp text. Users can expect thousands of pages from the included ink. Depending on whether you prioritize monochrome speed or color quality, your choice may vary.

Functionality

In terms of functionality, the Brother MFC-L2820DW is an all-in-one laser printer that includes print, copy, scan, and fax capabilities, making it versatile for various office tasks. It features a 50-page auto document feeder, which streamlines multi-page jobs. Conversely, the HP Smart Tank Plus 651 also serves as an all-in-one printer but emphasizes mobile printing, scanning, and copying with a focus on home use. This printer includes an auto document feeder as well, highlighting its capability for handling multiple tasks efficiently at home.

Connectivity Options

The Brother MFC-L2820DW offers multiple connectivity options including dual-band wireless (2.4GHz and 5GHz), Ethernet, and USB, allowing users to connect to various devices easily. Its flexible connection capabilities make it a strong contender for office environments where multiple devices need to connect seamlessly. In contrast, the HP Smart Tank Plus 651 is designed for home users, providing mobile and wireless printing without complicated setups. While both printers offer wireless connectivity, the Brother model's diverse options may appeal more to professional settings.

User Experience

User experience can significantly impact overall satisfaction. The Brother MFC-L2820DW features a 2.7-inch touchscreen for easy navigation, allowing users to print from and scan to popular cloud-based applications. Its design focuses on enhancing productivity in small office spaces. In comparison, the HP Smart Tank Plus 651 emphasizes a mess-free ink refill system, which simplifies maintenance. The ease of use in both models makes them appealing, but the Brother printer's touchscreen may provide a more intuitive user experience overall.

Maintenance and Durability

When it comes to maintenance, the HP Smart Tank Plus 651 shines with its cartridge-free design and comes with up to two years of ink included, reducing the hassle of frequent replacements. This model is built for longevity, promising less interruption in printing and fewer maintenance issues. The Brother MFC-L2820DW, while reliable, requires the purchase of specific toner cartridges, which might add to the long-term costs. For users looking for minimal upkeep, the HP model may be the preferred choice due to its innovative ink tank system.

Environmental Impact

Both printers are designed with sustainability in mind, but they approach it differently. The Brother MFC-L2820DW is ENERGY STAR® compliant and EPEAT® Silver rated, which indicates a commitment to energy efficiency and reducing environmental impact. This printer also features a Toner Save Mode to enhance cartridge life and reduce waste. Meanwhile, the HP Smart Tank Plus 651 promotes a refillable system that minimizes plastic waste associated with traditional ink cartridges. If eco-friendliness is a priority, both printers offer features that align with sustainable practices.

Which should you buy?

Ultimately, the decision between the Brother MFC-L2820DW and the HP Smart Tank Plus 651 depends on your specific needs. If you require a cost-effective solution for high-volume monochrome printing, the Brother model, priced at $279.99 and featuring robust office functionalities, is the clear winner. However, if you are looking for a home printer that excels in color quality and offers a hassle-free ink system, the HP Smart Tank Plus 651, with its two years of included ink and easier maintenance, may be the better option. Consider your printing volume, color needs, and budget to determine which printer aligns best with your requirements.