Canon PIXMA TR4720 All-in-One Wireless vs Canon PIXMA TS3720 Wireless All-in-One

Overview and Design

The Canon PIXMA TR4720 and Canon PIXMA TS3720 are both wireless all-in-one printers designed for home and small office environments. Both units belong to the Canon PIXMA line, known for integrating printing, copying, and scanning capabilities into compact form factors. The TR4720 is positioned as a 4-in-1 device, while the TS3720 operates as a 3-in-1 system. Physical design details regarding dimensions are not specified in the provided data, but both models emphasize easy ink cartridge installation and replacement. The TR4720 includes an auto document feeder, which suggests a design suited for higher volume document handling compared to the TS3720.

Printing Functionality

Functionality is a key differentiator between these two models. The Canon PIXMA TR4720 offers a 4-in-1 feature set, which includes printing, copying, scanning, and faxing. The inclusion of fax capabilities makes it more suitable for users who require traditional telephony integration for documents. In contrast, the Canon PIXMA TS3720 provides print, copy, and scan features only. Both devices are designed to produce quality documents and photos. The TR4720 specifically notes the ability to produce borderless prints up to 8.5 inches by 11 inches. The TS3720 supports versatile media including envelopes and high resolution paper, but lacks the fax module found in the TR4720.

Print Speed and Performance

Performance metrics indicate that the TR4720 holds an advantage in throughput speed. The TR4720 delivers print speeds of 8.8 images per minute for black documents and 4.4 images per minute for color documents. The TS3720 operates at approximately 7.7 images per minute for black and 4 images per minute for color. While the difference is marginal in color output, the black print speed on the TR4720 is notably higher. Both printers utilize easy-to-replace ink cartridges to maintain operation. The TR4720 also features an auto document feeder, which can enhance performance when scanning or copying multi-page documents without manual intervention.

Connectivity and Compatibility

Connectivity options vary between the two units. The TS3720 specifies support for Dual Band Wi-Fi, operating on either 2.4GHz or 5GHz frequencies, which can provide a more stable and reliable connection in congested network environments. The TR4720 is listed as Wireless but does not specify band support. However, the TR4720 integrates with Alexa for smart home notifications regarding ink levels and smart reorders. The TS3720 emphasizes mobile device printing compatibility, supporting the Canon PRINT app, Apple AirPrint, and Mopria Print Service. Additionally, the TS3720 explicitly states compatibility with Chromebook devices, allowing for hassle-free printing of schoolwork and documents.

Paper Handling and Media Support

Paper handling capabilities differ significantly regarding capacity and duplexing. The Canon PIXMA TR4720 features a 100-sheet paper capacity and supports auto 2-sided printing. This automatic duplexing allows users to print on both sides of the page without manual flipping, saving paper and time. The TS3720 is limited to single-sided printing only. Regarding media support, the TS3720 lists support for envelopes, photos, high resolution paper, and banners. The TR4720 supports borderless prints up to 8.5 inches by 11 inches. The presence of an auto document feeder on the TR4720 further enhances its paper handling for multi-page scanning tasks compared to the flatbed-only implication of the TS3720.

Power Efficiency and Maintenance

Power consumption data is available for the TR4720, which lists a consumption of 7W during operation, 0.8W in standby, and 0.3W when off. It also carries an ENERGY STAR certification, indicating compliance with energy efficiency guidelines. Power specifications for the TS3720 are not provided in the available data. Maintenance for both units focuses on ease of ink installation. The TR4720 offers Alexa integration to notify users when ink is low and can place smart reorders automatically if enrolled. The TS3720 utilizes 2 no-mess easy-to-replace ink cartridges. Both models aim to minimize user intervention during routine maintenance tasks.

Price and Value Proposition

The pricing structure favors the Canon PIXMA TR4720. It is listed at a price of $69.00, whereas the Canon PIXMA TS3720 is listed at $86.00. Despite the lower cost, the TR4720 offers superior specifications in terms of speed, duplex printing, and functionality with the inclusion of fax. The TS3720 commands a higher price while offering single-sided printing and fewer core functions, though it does include a 1.5 inch LCD screen which the TR4720 data does not mention. The TR4720 includes a 1 year limited warranty. Warranty details for the TS3720 are not specified. Overall, the TR4720 presents a higher value proposition based on feature density per dollar.

Final Verdict and Recommendation

Based on the provided specifications, the Canon PIXMA TR4720 is the recommended choice for most users. It outperforms the TS3720 in critical areas such as print speed, paper handling with auto duplexing, and overall functionality with fax support. The lower price point of $69.00 further solidifies its position as the better value. The TS3720 may appeal to users who specifically require Dual Band Wi-Fi stability or a built-in LCD screen for navigation. However, for general home office use involving document production and cost efficiency, the TR4720 delivers superior performance and features. Buyers should select the TR4720 for productivity and the TS3720 only if specific connectivity or interface features are prioritized over print speed and duplexing.