Canon PIXMA TS3720 Wireless All-in-One vs HP OfficeJet Pro 9125e Wireless

Design and Build Quality

The Canon PIXMA TS3720 is designed with a compact form factor suitable for home desks. It features a 1.5 inch segment LCD screen that provides an intuitive interface for navigating settings without needing a computer. The build focuses on simplicity, utilizing only 2 easy-to-replace ink cartridges to minimize mess during installation. In contrast, the HP OfficeJet Pro 9125e is built for office environments with a larger footprint to accommodate its upgraded features. It includes a 250-sheet input tray, suggesting a more robust paper handling design intended for higher volume workflows. While the Canon prioritizes a small footprint, the HP prioritizes capacity and professional durability.

Printing Functionality

Functionality differs significantly between these two all-in-one units. The Canon PIXMA TS3720 covers the essential basics with Print, Copy, and Scan features, giving users full control at their fingertips for standard document tasks. It is strictly limited to single-sided printing, requiring manual intervention for double-sided documents. The HP OfficeJet Pro 9125e expands on this foundation by adding Fax capabilities and an auto document feeder. This makes the HP model more versatile for business users who need to process multi-page documents automatically. The inclusion of fax and automatic feeding positions the HP unit as a more comprehensive office solution compared to the home-focused Canon.

Print Speed and Performance

Performance metrics highlight the intended use cases for each printer. The Canon PIXMA TS3720 offers print speeds of approximately 7.7 images per minute for black documents and 4 images per minute for color. These speeds are adequate for occasional home use but may bottleneck larger jobs. The HP OfficeJet Pro 9125e delivers significantly higher throughput, with speeds up to 22 ppm for black and 18 ppm for color. This performance gap is substantial, allowing the HP model to handle professional-quality color documents like presentations and brochures much more efficiently. Users prioritizing time efficiency will find the HP speeds markedly superior.

Paper Handling and Media

Paper handling capabilities further distinguish the two models. The Canon PIXMA TS3720 supports versatile media types including envelopes, photos, and high resolution paper, making it suitable for creative home projects. However, it lacks information regarding a specific input tray capacity in the provided data. The HP OfficeJet Pro 9125e features a 250-sheet input tray, which reduces the frequency of refilling paper during heavy use. Additionally, the HP model supports auto 2-sided printing, which saves paper and creates professional booklets without manual flipping. The Canon requires manual handling for duplex tasks, which can be less efficient for large batches.

Connectivity and Wireless Options

Both printers offer modern wireless connectivity to ensure flexible placement within a workspace. The Canon PIXMA TS3720 establishes a stable and reliable connection with Dual Band Wi-Fi, supporting both 2.4GHz and 5GHz frequencies. It also features Easy Wireless Connect, allowing setup without a computer. The HP OfficeJet Pro 9125e similarly utilizes reliable dual-band Wi-Fi that automatically detects and resolves connection issues. Both devices support mobile device printing, ensuring users can print from smartphones or tablets regardless of the brand chosen. The connectivity parity means neither device has a distinct advantage in getting online.

Software and Ecosystem

Software integration varies based on the manufacturer's ecosystem. The Canon PIXMA TS3720 works with the free Canon PRINT app, Apple AirPrint, and Mopria Print Service. It is also compatible with Chromebook, facilitating hassle-free printing for students. The HP OfficeJet Pro 9125e utilizes the HP App for printing, scanning, copying, or faxing from smartphones, PCs, or tablets. Uniquely, HP introduces HP AI to format web pages and emails precisely, removing unwanted content before printing. HP also promotes its Instant Ink delivery service, which automates ink replenishment. Canon focuses on standard compatibility, while HP adds AI formatting and subscription services.

Price and Value

Price is the most significant differentiator between these two units. The Canon PIXMA TS3720 is listed at $86.00, making it an accessible entry-level option. Its value proposition lies in the low upfront cost and the simplicity of using 2 no-mess ink cartridges. The HP OfficeJet Pro 9125e is priced at $219.89, reflecting its higher performance and feature set. It includes 3 months of Instant Ink with HP+ activation, though a monthly fee applies afterward unless cancelled. For budget-conscious buyers, the Canon offers better immediate value, while the HP offers better long-term productivity value for offices willing to invest in higher speeds and automation.

Which One Should You Buy?

Choosing between these printers depends on your specific volume and feature requirements. If you need a device for occasional home use, schoolwork, or photo printing on a budget, the Canon PIXMA TS3720 is the logical choice due to its low price and simple setup. However, if you run a small office or require high-volume printing with professional formatting, the HP OfficeJet Pro 9125e is the winner. Its faster speeds, automatic duplexing, and fax capabilities justify the higher price tag for users who need efficiency. Ultimately, the HP model wins on performance, while the Canon model wins on affordability.