CRAFTSMAN V20 Cordless Jig Saw Kit, 3 Orbital vs DeWalt DW317 Vs Orbital Jigsaw

Introduction

When it comes to jigsaws, both the CRAFTSMAN V20 Cordless Jig Saw Kit and the DeWalt DW317 Vs Orbital Jigsaw stand out as solid choices. Each offers unique features that cater to different user preferences and needs. In this comparison, we will examine their key characteristics, pricing, performance, and usability to help you make an informed decision.

Pricing

The CRAFTSMAN V20 Cordless Jig Saw Kit is priced at $159.00, while the DeWalt DW317 is slightly more affordable at $139.00, making it about 17% cheaper than its competitor. The price difference may influence budget-conscious buyers, particularly those seeking reliable performance without breaking the bank. However, the CRAFTSMAN offers the added value of a complete kit, including a battery and charger, which can be essential for cordless operation.

Power and Performance

Power and performance are critical factors when choosing a jigsaw. The DeWalt DW317 boasts a 5.5 Amp motor, allowing for powerful cuts in some of the hardest materials. It delivers a variable speed of up to 3,100 strokes per minute, which is higher than the CRAFTSMAN's maximum of 2,500 SPM. This capability means that the DeWalt may provide faster cutting speeds, especially in tougher jobs. However, the CRAFTSMAN compensates for this with its three orbital settings, allowing for a more tailored cut aggressiveness, which can be beneficial for different materials and applications.

Cutting Features

Both jigsaws offer impressive cutting features tailored to various user needs. The CRAFTSMAN V20 allows for clean, accurate cuts with its variable speed trigger and three orbital settings for adjusting cut aggressiveness. In contrast, the DeWalt DW317 features a four-position orbital action, providing an even greater variety of cutting options. This means that while both jigsaws can handle different materials well, the DeWalt may offer more versatility for aggressive cutting tasks, making it an appealing choice for professionals or avid DIYers.

Blade Change Mechanism

Ease of use is vital for jigsaw users, particularly when it comes to changing blades. The DeWalt DW317 features a keyless blade clamp, allowing for quick blade changes without the need to touch the blade or reciprocating shaft. This feature can save time and reduce hassle during projects. The CRAFTSMAN, while not specifically noted for its blade change mechanism, focuses more on providing comfort and control during cutting. For those who frequently switch blades, the DeWalt offers a clear advantage in convenience.

Build Quality and Durability

When it comes to build quality, the DeWalt DW317 is constructed with an all-metal gear case, which enhances its durability, especially in professional settings. This design choice is aimed at providing longevity for users who put their tools through rigorous use. The CRAFTSMAN V20 also emphasizes user comfort with its contoured over-molded handle that helps reduce fatigue during prolonged use. While both tools are designed to withstand regular use, the DeWalt's construction may give it an edge in terms of durability.

User Comfort

User comfort is another significant aspect of jigsaw usage. The CRAFTSMAN V20 is designed with a contoured over-molded handle that enhances grip and reduces user fatigue, making it a solid option for extended projects. On the other hand, the DeWalt DW317 does not explicitly mention comfort features, but its powerful motor and variable speed settings may contribute to ease of use in various cutting situations. Ultimately, while both tools are designed for user comfort, the CRAFTSMAN's focus on ergonomics may be more appealing for those who prioritize comfort during long cutting sessions.

Portability and Convenience

In terms of portability, the CRAFTSMAN V20 Cordless Jig Saw Kit has a clear advantage due to its cordless design, which allows for greater freedom of movement without the limitations of a power cord. This feature is particularly beneficial for users who need to work in spaces without easy access to power outlets. The DeWalt DW317, being corded, may require careful planning around power sources but compensates with its powerful performance. For those prioritizing mobility and convenience, the CRAFTSMAN is the better option.

Which should you buy?

Deciding between the CRAFTSMAN V20 Cordless Jig Saw Kit and the DeWalt DW317 ultimately depends on your specific needs and preferences. If you value portability, comfort, and a complete kit with a battery and charger, the CRAFTSMAN is a strong contender at $159.00. However, if you seek power, faster cutting speeds, and a durable build, the DeWalt DW317 at $139.00 may be the right choice for you. Each tool has its strengths, making it essential to consider your priorities before making a purchase.