DEWALT 20V MAX XR Brushless Cordless 7-1/4 in. vs Makita XSR01Z 36V LXT® Brushless Rear Handle

Overview of the DEWALT and Makita Circular Saws

The DEWALT 20V MAX XR Brushless Cordless Circular Saw Kit is priced at $369.03, while the Makita XSR01Z 36V Circular Saw, sold as a tool only, is available for $241.65. This means the DEWALT is about 53% more expensive than the Makita. Both saws are well-regarded in the market, with the DEWALT holding a sales rank of 79,912 and the Makita being significantly more popular at a sales rank of 30,684. This comparison will delve into various aspects of both saws to help you understand which might be the better investment for your needs.

Power and Performance

When it comes to power, the DEWALT excels with a maximum output of 1,700 MWO and a brushless motor that can reach up to 5,500 RPM. In contrast, the Makita features a BL Brushless Motor that delivers 5,100 RPM. Although both motors are designed for efficiency, the DEWALT's higher RPM provides an edge in speed during use. Furthermore, the DEWALT can make about 368 cuts per charge, which is quite impressive. The Makita, while slightly lower in maximum RPM, boasts a remarkable cutting capacity of 2-9/16 inches at a 90-degree angle, allowing it to handle larger materials in a single pass.

Design and Usability

Both circular saws prioritize user comfort and ease of use, but they differ significantly in design. The DEWALT features a blade located to the right of the motor and a top handle position, which is particularly beneficial for precision cutting on challenging job sites. Conversely, the Makita showcases a blade-left rear-handle design, which many users of traditional corded saws may find more familiar. The DEWALT's electric brake system stops the blade quickly after the trigger is released, enhancing safety. The Makita also includes an electric brake, alongside a die-cast magnesium base that contributes to its durability while keeping the weight manageable at 12.4 lbs.

Battery and Runtime

Battery power is a critical factor in cordless saw performance, and both brands employ innovative technology. The DEWALT operates on a 20V MAX battery system, whereas the Makita uses an 18V X2 system, effectively providing 36V of power. The DEWALT’s battery allows for about 368 cuts per charge, while the Makita can achieve up to 558 cross-cuts in 2x4 SPF lumber using two 5.0Ah batteries (sold separately). This indicates that the Makita may deliver better runtime efficiency, especially for heavy-duty tasks, making it a strong contender for extended use without frequent recharges.

Cutting Capacity and Versatility

In terms of cutting capacity, both saws offer impressive capabilities. The DEWALT can achieve a maximum depth of cut of 2-9/16 inches at 90 degrees and 2 inches at 45 degrees, while the Makita also matches the depth of cut at 2-9/16 inches at 90 degrees. This makes both tools versatile for various materials, including thick lumber. The DEWALT's adjustable bevel capacity of 57 degrees with stops at 45 and 22.5 degrees adds to its versatility, allowing for greater flexibility in cutting angles. Meanwhile, the Makita's automatic speed change technology further optimizes cutting performance based on the material, providing an advantage in dynamic cutting conditions.

Durability and Build Quality

Both the DEWALT and Makita are constructed with durability in mind, but they take slightly different approaches. The DEWALT's robust design focuses on high-performance cutting, while the Makita’s die-cast magnesium base offers a lightweight yet sturdy alternative, making it easier to handle without compromising on strength. The Makita also emphasizes longevity with its brushless motor, which eliminates the need for carbon brushes, allowing it to run cooler and more efficiently over time. This design choice can lead to a longer lifespan for the tool, making it a solid option for professionals who demand reliability in their equipment.

Price Comparison

The DEWALT is priced at $369.03, making it a significant investment compared to the Makita's $241.65 price point. This price difference of about $127.38 means that the Makita is approximately 34% cheaper than the DEWALT. While the DEWALT offers additional features and potentially higher performance metrics, the Makita provides excellent value, especially for users who may not require the utmost power or the full kit, as it is sold as a tool only.

Which should you buy?

Choosing between the DEWALT 20V MAX XR Circular Saw Kit and the Makita XSR01Z 36V Circular Saw ultimately depends on your specific needs. If you prioritize maximum power and prefer a full kit with battery and charger, the DEWALT may be worth the higher investment. However, if you seek a budget-friendly option with excellent runtime and a strong performance for standard cutting tasks, the Makita presents a compelling case. Both saws have their strengths, but careful consideration of your cutting requirements and budget will guide you to the right choice.