DEWALT 20V MAX XR Jig Saw vs DeWalt DW317 Vs Orbital Jigsaw

Price Comparison

The DEWALT 20V MAX XR Jig Saw is priced at $355.58, while the DeWalt DW317 Vs Orbital Jigsaw is significantly more affordable at $139.00. This makes the DW317 about 61% cheaper than the DCS334P1. If budget is a primary concern, the DW317 offers a compelling value without sacrificing essential features. The price difference may reflect the advanced features of the 20V MAX XR, but for those who need a reliable jigsaw for general tasks, the DW317 presents a more economical choice.

Motor Performance

The DCS334P1 is equipped with a brushless motor that is designed for efficient performance and extended runtime, which is particularly beneficial for long projects. In contrast, the DW317 features a 5.5 Amp motor that delivers powerful cuts, reaching up to 3,100 strokes per minute. While the brushless motor of the DCS334P1 may provide a longer operational life, the DW317's motor is robust enough for most tasks, making it suitable for both DIY enthusiasts and professionals. The motor performance is a crucial factor for users who require reliability and power in their jigsaw.

Cutting Speed

In terms of cutting speed, the DCS334P1 offers a variable-speed trigger and dial that provides precise speed control, achieving a maximum of 3,200 strokes per minute. This feature can be particularly advantageous when working with various materials that require different cutting speeds. Conversely, the DW317 also allows for variable speed but caps at 3,100 strokes per minute. The slight difference in speed might not be significant for most users, but for those who prioritize cutting versatility, the DCS334P1 has a slight edge.

Orbital Action

Both jigsaws boast 4-position orbital action, which allows for better control over cut quality and speed. The DCS334P1 offers this feature to optimize the cutting performance for different materials, whether softer woods or denser materials. The DW317 similarly allows for faster, more aggressive cuts, making it versatile for a range of applications. The presence of orbital action in both tools suggests that users can expect efficient cutting results; however, the DCS334P1 may offer additional benefits in terms of fine-tuning for specific tasks.

Ease of Use

When it comes to user-friendliness, the DCS334P1 includes an all-metal, lever-action keyless blade clamp that facilitates quick and easy blade changes, which is a significant advantage for users frequently switching between tasks. The integrated dust blower also enhances visibility during cutting, keeping the line of sight clear. The DW317 features a keyless blade clamp as well, allowing for quick changes without touching the blade. Both jigsaws are designed to enhance user experience, but the additional features of the DCS334P1 may provide a more seamless operation, especially in dimly lit environments.

Durability and Build Quality

The durability of a jigsaw is vital for professional use. The DW317 is constructed with an all-metal gear case, ensuring superior durability on job sites. The DCS334P1, while not specified to have an all-metal housing, is designed with a robust construction aimed at providing long-lasting performance. The durability of both tools makes them suitable for a variety of cutting tasks; however, the DW317 may have a slight advantage when it comes to heavy-duty applications due to its all-metal design.

Battery vs. Corded Power

The DCS334P1 is a cordless jigsaw powered by a 20V MAX* XR battery, which allows for unrestricted movement while working. This feature is especially beneficial for outdoor or large-scale projects where access to power outlets may be limited. On the other hand, the DW317 is a corded jigsaw, which means it will provide consistent power without the need for battery replacements or recharging. The decision between battery and corded power largely depends on the user's working style; those who prefer mobility may lean towards the DCS334P1, while users favoring continuous power might prefer the DW317.

Which should you buy?

Choosing between the DEWALT 20V MAX XR Jig Saw and the DeWalt DW317 Vs Orbital Jigsaw ultimately comes down to your specific needs and budget. The DCS334P1 offers advanced features like a brushless motor, higher cutting speed, and cordless convenience, making it ideal for frequent users who need versatility and performance. However, at a price point of $139.00, the DW317 provides excellent value, delivering solid performance for casual users or those with budget constraints. If you require a powerful, feature-rich jigsaw, the DCS334P1 is worth the investment, but for practical, everyday tasks, the DW317 stands as a strong contender.