DEWALT 20V MAX XR Jig Saw, vs Makita XVJ04Z 18V LXT® Lithium-Ion

Overview and Design

The DEWALT 20V MAX XR and Makita XVJ04Z represent two prominent options in the cordless jigsaw category. Both tools utilize brushless motor technology to enhance efficiency and runtime. The DEWALT model focuses on compact sizing for easy grip and maximum control. In contrast, the Makita unit emphasizes variable speed delivery and specific cutting modes. Each tool includes an LED light to illuminate work surfaces, addressing visibility concerns in dimly lit environments. While both are physical power tools designed for cutting tasks, their feature sets cater to slightly different priorities regarding adjustment and speed specification.

Motor Performance

Both jigsaws employ brushless motors, which generally provide longer runtime and efficient performance compared to brushed alternatives. The DEWALT motor is noted for delivering efficient performance for longer runtime when compared to its previous DCS331 model. The Makita motor is described as a brushless variable speed motor that delivers 0-3,000 strokes per minute. This specific metric allows users to understand the maximum cutting speed capability of the Makita tool. The DEWALT data does not specify a strokes per minute number, focusing instead on the efficiency gains over its predecessor. Both motors support variable speed control through their respective triggers.

Battery System

Power delivery is determined by the voltage platform each tool belongs to. The DEWALT jigsaw operates on a 20V MAX system, which is a common standard for heavy-duty cordless tools in its brand ecosystem. The Makita jigsaw operates on an 18V LXT Lithium-Ion platform. While voltage numbers differ, both platforms are designed to provide sufficient power for cutting various materials. Users already invested in either brand's battery ecosystem will find compatibility with their existing chargers and cells. The higher voltage number on the DEWALT may suggest a higher power potential, though actual performance depends on motor engineering and battery amp-hour ratings not listed here.

Control Features

User interface and control mechanisms differ between the two models. The DEWALT unit features a variable speed trigger and dial to provide precise speed control. This combination allows users to set a maximum speed limit via the dial while modulating pressure on the trigger. The Makita tool utilizes a large 2-finger variable speed trigger for added convenience. Additionally, the Makita includes a lock-on button, which allows for continuous operation without holding the trigger continuously. The DEWALT data does not mention a lock-on feature. Both tools aim to provide precise control over the cutting process through these variable speed mechanisms.

Orbital Action Settings

Orbital action influences the aggressiveness of the cut and the speed at which material is removed. The DEWALT jigsaw provides 4-position orbital action, which offers control of cut quality and speed. This gives the user four distinct settings to match the material being cut. The Makita model offers 3 orbital settings plus straight cutting for use in a wide range of materials. While both provide orbital options, the DEWALT lists a higher number of orbital positions. The straight cutting mode on the Makita is explicitly mentioned alongside its three orbital settings. These settings allow users to balance between finish quality and cutting speed.

Visibility and Lighting

Working in low-light conditions is common in construction and woodworking. Both manufacturers have integrated lighting solutions to address this. The DEWALT tool includes a bright LED on the jigsaw tool to help illuminate dimly lit work surfaces. Similarly, the Makita features a built-in L.E.D. light that illuminates the work area. Neither specification details the lumens or positioning of the lights, but both confirm the presence of this feature. Additionally, the DEWALT includes an integrated dust blower to help clear line of sight while cutting. This helps maintain visibility by removing debris from the cut line, complementing the LED light.

Build and Adjustments

Physical adjustments and build quality determine how well the tool adapts to different cutting angles. The DEWALT jigsaw features an all-metal, keyless shoe bevel with detents at 0 degree, 15 degree, 30 degree, and a positive stop at 45 degree for easy adjustment. This provides clear, repeatable angles for bevel cuts. It also includes a no-mar shoe cover to help protect work surface from scratches. The Makita data does not specify shoe bevel angles or protective covers. For blade changes, the DEWALT uses an all-metal, lever-action keyless blade change for quick and easy t-shank blade changes. The Makita data does not specify the blade change mechanism. Both accept t-shank blades for optimal holding power.

Price and Value

Cost is a significant differentiator between these two cordless jigsaws. The DEWALT 20V MAX XR is listed at a price of $125.00. The Makita XVJ04Z is listed at a price of $199.00. This represents a price difference of $74.00 in favor of the DEWALT model. Given that both tools offer brushless motors, LED lights, and orbital action, the DEWALT provides a lower entry point for similar core functionality. The Makita commands a premium price, potentially justified by its specific speed metrics and comfort features like the lock-on button. For users prioritizing budget and adjustable orbital settings, the DEWALT presents a strong value proposition.