DEWALT ATOMIC 20V MAX* Circular Saw, 4-1/2-Inch, Tool Only vs Makita XSH04ZB 18V LXT® Lithium-Ion Sub-Compact

Overview of the Products

In the compact circular saw category, the DEWALT ATOMIC 20V MAX* Circular Saw stands out with a notable price of $159.00, while the Makita XSH04ZB 18V LXT® Circular Saw is priced at $189.00. This results in the DEWALT being about 16% cheaper than the Makita model. Both saws cater to different user needs, with unique features that enhance their usability and performance, making them competitive options for both professionals and DIY enthusiasts.

Design and Ergonomics

The DEWALT ATOMIC is designed for ease of use with a removable auxiliary handle that enhances control during operation. Its compact size allows for versatile handling, especially for intricate cuts. Meanwhile, the Makita XSH04ZB features an ergonomic blade-right design that is only 10-5/8 inches long and weighs just 6.4 lbs with a 2.0Ah battery. This lightweight construction aims to provide comfort during extended use. Users seeking a lightweight and easily maneuverable saw may find the Makita more appealing, while those who prioritize control might prefer the DEWALT's handle design.

Cutting Performance

In terms of cutting capabilities, the DEWALT can cut up to 369 linear feet of 3/4 inch OSB using a compatible battery, making it efficient for larger projects. The Makita, on the other hand, boasts a maximum cutting depth of 2-1/4 inches at 90 degrees and a bevel capacity of up to 50 degrees, which allows for versatile cuts in various materials. For users focused on precision cutting, the Makita might offer more versatility with its bevel adjustments, whereas the DEWALT's linear cutting efficiency may cater better to bulk cutting tasks.

Motor and Speed

The DEWALT features a brushless motor that enhances efficiency and productivity, allowing for quick cuts and fast blade stops due to its electronic blade brake. In comparison, the Makita's BL Brushless motor delivers a powerful 5,000 RPM, ensuring faster cutting and ripping capabilities. The advanced motor technology in both saws ensures longer tool life and better performance, but the Makita's higher RPM could make it more suitable for users requiring rapid cutting in demanding applications.

Battery and Runtime

Both saws operate on their respective battery systems, with the DEWALT using the 20V MAX* batteries and the Makita utilizing the 18V LXT battery system. The DEWALT does not include a battery, which is sold separately, as does the Makita, but the Makita’s efficient motor is designed to provide up to 50% longer runtime compared to non-brushless motors. This difference may lead some users to prefer the Makita for extended use on the job, particularly when equipped with higher amp-hour batteries.

Safety Features

Safety is a significant consideration in power tools, and both the DEWALT and Makita incorporate essential safety features. The DEWALT includes an electronic blade brake that stops the blade quickly, enhancing user safety and productivity. In contrast, the Makita also features an electric brake and adds dual LED lights for improved visibility of the cut line in low-light conditions. While both models prioritize safety, the additional LED lights on the Makita may provide a practical advantage for users working in dim environments.

Additional Features

The DEWALT ATOMIC includes a hang hook for added convenience and on-board blade key storage, which facilitates quick blade changes. Meanwhile, the Makita XSH04ZB is equipped with Extreme Protection Technology (XPT), improving its resistance to dust and water, which is crucial for harsh job site conditions. These additional features make the DEWALT more user-friendly for quick adjustments, while the Makita's durability may appeal to those working in more demanding environments.

Which should you buy?

Ultimately, the choice between the DEWALT ATOMIC 20V MAX* Circular Saw and the Makita XSH04ZB 18V LXT® Circular Saw comes down to specific user needs. The DEWALT is priced at $159.00, making it a cost-effective option with excellent cutting efficiency and user-friendly features. Conversely, the Makita, priced at $189.00, offers superior cutting speed and a robust design suited for extended use in challenging conditions. Users focused on lightweight operation and versatility may lean towards the Makita, while those interested in a more economical choice with solid performance may prefer the DEWALT.