DeWalt DW317 Vs Orbital Jigsaw vs TaskStar Cordless Jig Saw Tool

Price Comparison

When considering price, the TaskStar Cordless Jig Saw is significantly more economical, retailing at $89.99 compared to the DeWalt DW317 Vs Orbital Jigsaw, which is priced at $139.00. This makes the TaskStar about 36% cheaper than the DeWalt model. While the DeWalt has a respectable sales rank of 322,669, the TaskStar boasts a better position at 76,101, indicating its popularity in the market. For those on a budget or seeking value, the TaskStar presents a compelling option without compromising on essential features.

Power and Performance

In terms of power, the DeWalt DW317 excels with its 5.5 Amp motor, delivering robust performance for cutting through tough materials. It achieves variable speeds of up to 3,100 strokes per minute, which is particularly advantageous for achieving optimal cutting speed. On the other hand, the TaskStar Cordless Jig Saw, while versatile, does not specify its motor power but emphasizes dual 2.0Ah batteries that provide up to 40 minutes of runtime. This means while the DeWalt is engineered for heavy-duty tasks, the TaskStar is designed for convenience and mobility, making it suitable for lighter jobs.

Cutting Versatility

Both jigsaws offer impressive cutting versatility, but they approach it differently. The DeWalt DW317 features a 4-position orbital action, allowing for faster, more aggressive cuts in various materials. This makes it ideal for professionals who need to switch between different cutting styles rapidly. Conversely, the TaskStar Cordless Jig Saw includes 9 blades specifically designed for wood, metal, and plastic, along with 4 orbital settings. This versatility caters to DIY enthusiasts and light professional needs, although it may lack the aggressive cutting capability of the DeWalt.

Ease of Use

When it comes to ease of use, the TaskStar Cordless Jig Saw shines with its tool-free blade change mechanism, allowing for quick and secure blade swaps in seconds. This is especially useful for projects requiring frequent blade changes. Meanwhile, the DeWalt DW317 features a keyless blade clamp that also enables quick blade changes but may not be as user-friendly as the TaskStar's system. Additionally, the TaskStar's built-in LED light enhances visibility during cutting, making it easier to work in dimly lit conditions. This focus on user experience makes the TaskStar a strong contender in this category.

Durability and Build Quality

Durability is another crucial factor in choosing a jigsaw. The DeWalt DW317 is constructed with an all-metal gear case, which ensures superior durability suitable for professional environments. This construction is critical for users who require a tool that can withstand rigorous use. In contrast, the TaskStar Cordless Jig Saw, while lightweight and easy to handle, does not emphasize durability in the same way. It is designed for more casual use, so those who frequently engage in heavy-duty tasks may prefer the sturdiness of the DeWalt.

Battery and Cordless Features

The TaskStar Cordless Jig Saw stands out with its dual 2.0Ah batteries, offering cordless freedom that enhances maneuverability and convenience. With a recharge time of 1-2 hours, users can enjoy uninterrupted cutting tasks. The DeWalt DW317, being a corded model, does not offer the same level of mobility but ensures consistent power without worrying about battery life. Users should consider their working environment; if portability is essential, the TaskStar is the preferable choice, whereas those who prioritize sustained power may lean towards the DeWalt.

Brand Reputation

Brand reputation can significantly influence buyer decisions, and here, DeWalt has a long-standing reputation for quality and reliability in the power tool market. The DeWalt DW317, with its professional-grade features, aligns with the expectations of contractors and serious DIYers alike. The TaskStar, while gaining traction, is a lesser-known brand compared to DeWalt. However, its growing sales rank suggests that it is making a name for itself, particularly among budget-conscious consumers looking for solid performance at a lower price point.

Which should you buy?

Ultimately, choosing between the DeWalt DW317 Vs Orbital Jigsaw and the TaskStar Cordless Jig Saw depends on your specific needs. If you require a powerful, durable tool for demanding tasks, the DeWalt is the clear choice, despite its higher price. However, if budget is a significant factor and you value versatility and portability, the TaskStar offers excellent features at a more attractive price point. For casual users and DIY enthusiasts, the TaskStar is likely the better option, while professionals may prefer the DeWalt for its robust performance and reliability.