DeWalt DW317 Vs Orbital Jigsaw vs Worx 20V Power Share Jigsaw - WX543L.9

Price Comparison

The Worx 20V Power Share Jigsaw is significantly less expensive than the DeWalt DW317, making it about 57% cheaper at $58.98 compared to the DeWalt's price of $139.00. This stark difference in price may appeal to hobbyists or casual users who need a reliable jigsaw without a hefty investment. Conversely, the DeWalt DW317 is designed for professional use, justifying its higher price point with its robust features and durability. If budget constraints are a priority, the Worx jigsaw offers excellent value without sacrificing essential performance features.

Performance and Power

In terms of performance, the DeWalt DW317 boasts a more powerful 5.5 Amp motor compared to the Worx jigsaw's lower capacity, with a no-load speed reaching up to 3,100 strokes per minute. This makes the DeWalt more suitable for cutting through tougher materials with ease. On the other hand, the Worx jigsaw provides a maximum no-load speed of 2,600 RPM, which is still adequate for most woodworking tasks. For users needing extensive cutting power and speed, the DeWalt is the clear choice, while the Worx may suffice for lighter projects.

Cutting Versatility

Both jigsaws offer variable speed control, but the DeWalt DW317 features a 4-position orbital action that allows for more aggressive cuts in various materials. This feature enhances versatility, enabling users to tackle a wider range of cutting tasks. The Worx jigsaw also includes an orbital/pendulum function, promoting efficiency in cutting strokes, but it remains a step behind in terms of adjustable orbital settings. If you prioritize versatility and the ability to handle diverse materials, the DeWalt provides superior options.

Design and Ergonomics

The Worx jigsaw stands out for its ergonomic barrel-grip design, which aids in maintaining steady cuts during extended use. Weighing in at only 5.3 lbs with the battery, it is easier to handle and maneuver, making it ideal for one-handed operation. In contrast, the DeWalt DW317 is built for durability with an all-metal gear case, which may add some weight but ensures longevity on professional job sites. While both designs have their merits, the Worx’s lightweight design gives it an edge for users who prioritize comfort and ease of use.

Blade Change Mechanism

Both jigsaws feature tool-less blade change systems, allowing users to swap out blades quickly and easily without the need for additional tools. This feature is especially beneficial for those who frequently switch between different materials. However, the DeWalt's keyless blade clamp is specifically designed to allow for quick blade changes without touching the blade or the reciprocating shaft, which adds a layer of convenience in maintaining safety. While the Worx also provides an easy blade change process, the DeWalt's design may offer a slight advantage in terms of user safety and efficiency.

Additional Features

The Worx 20V Power Share Jigsaw comes equipped with several additional features that enhance user experience, such as a vacuum attachment for cleaner workspaces and an onboard LED light for improved visibility on cut lines. These features are valuable for users working in less-than-ideal lighting conditions or those who prefer to maintain a tidy workspace. While the DeWalt DW317 lacks these specific extras, it compensates with its rugged build and high-powered motor, making it more suited for heavy-duty tasks. Users looking for more functional extras may find the Worx jigsaw more appealing.

Sales and Popularity

The DeWalt DW317 has a bestseller rank of 322,669, while the Worx jigsaw ranks significantly higher at 205,533. This suggests that the Worx may have broader appeal, possibly due to its lower price point and user-friendly features. However, the DeWalt’s ranking reflects its reputation within professional circles where performance and durability are critical. For those prioritizing popularity and user approval, the Worx seems to attract more attention, whereas the DeWalt is favored for its industrial reliability.

Which should you buy?

Ultimately, your choice between the DeWalt DW317 and the Worx 20V Power Share Jigsaw should be guided by your specific needs and budget. If you require a powerful tool for professional-grade tasks and are willing to invest in quality, the DeWalt DW317 is the better option. However, if you are looking for an affordable, versatile jigsaw for home projects, the Worx jigsaw offers excellent performance at a fraction of the price. Weighing the importance of power, features, and price will help you make the best decision for your jigsaw needs.