DEWALT FLEXVOLT ADVANTAGE 20V MAX* Combo vs Makita XT297T 18V LXT® Lithium-Ion

Design and build quality

The DEWALT FLEXVOLT ADVANTAGE 20V MAX* Combo and the Makita XT297T 18V LXT® Lithium-Ion kit represent two distinct approaches to cordless tool design. The DEWALT set focuses on compatibility across voltage platforms, ensuring both cordless hammer drills work with all DEWALT 20V MAX* and FLEXVOLT Batteries. This flexibility allows users to leverage higher voltage packs for increased performance. The Makita kit emphasizes lightweight construction, with the hammer driver-drill weighing only 6.0 lbs. with battery and the impact driver weighing only 3.4 lbs. with battery. This weight reduction is critical for users who operate tools overhead or for extended periods where fatigue is a concern.

Power and Performance

When evaluating raw power, the DEWALT DCD999 hammer drill claims a significant advantage under specific conditions. It gets up to 42% more power when paired with FLEXVOLT batteries, offering a scalable performance metric depending on the battery used. In contrast, the Makita variable 2-speed Hammer Driver-Drill provides concrete torque specifications, delivering 1,250 in.lbs. of Max Torque. The Makita impact driver further specifies its output with 1,590 in.lbs. of Max Torque. While DEWALT offers potential peak power through voltage adaptation, Makita provides verified torque numbers that allow for precise application matching without needing specific high-voltage packs.

Battery and Charging

Battery ecosystem compatibility is a strong point for the DEWALT combo. The included DCB1106 6 Amp Charger is compatible with 20V MAX* batteries and FLEXVOLT 20V/60V MAX* batteries, providing a unified charging solution for mixed fleets. The high amperage suggests faster replenishment times for compatible packs. Makita focuses on energy optimization within the tool itself. The efficient Makita-built Brushless Motor is electronically controlled to optimize battery energy use for up to 50% longer run time per charge. This approach extends work sessions without necessarily requiring a higher output charger, relying instead on motor efficiency to maximize the utility of the 18V LXT platform.

Lighting and Visibility

Visibility features differ significantly between the two kits. The DEWALT DCD999 features a 3-mode LED that provides lighting in dark or confined spaces up to 20x brighter than the DEWALT DCD985. Additionally, the DCF887 impact driver creates visibility without shadows from 3 LEDs with a 20-second delay after trigger is released. The DEWALT spotlight mode also features a 20 minute shutoff function allowing for extended work time in dark or confined spaces. Makita utilizes an Impact Driver L.E.D. light ring that provides superior 360° illumination helps eliminate shadows and illuminate a larger area. While DEWALT offers higher intensity and duration controls, Makita offers omnidirectional coverage.

Control and Precision

Precision handling is addressed through speed settings and drive controls. The DEWALT DCF887 has application versatility with 3-speed settings and helps prevent over-tightening fasteners with added control from Precision Drive in speed 1 setting. This is particularly useful for delicate fastening tasks. The Makita impact driver features a rear handle positioned 4-speed power selection providing varied RPM and IPM ranges including 0-3,600 / 0-3,800 IPM. The electronically-controlled brushless motor efficiently uses energy to match torque and RPM to the changing demands of the application. Makita offers more speed selections, while DEWALT offers specific anti-over-tightening logic.

Durability and Protection

Environmental protection is a key differentiator for professional use. The Makita kit features Extreme Protection Technology (XPT) is engineered for improved dust and water resistance for operation in harsh conditions. It is also Equipped with Star Protection Computer Controls to protect against overloading, over-discharging and over-heating. The DEWALT DCD999 is Tool Connect Chip Ready, where the Chip pocket accepts Tool Connect Chip DCE042. This focuses on asset management and tracking rather than environmental sealing. For users in dusty or wet environments, Makita's XPT provides a tangible durability advantage regarding component longevity.

Price and Value

Cost is a primary factor for many buyers. The Makita XT297T is priced at $372.17, while the DEWALT FLEXVOLT ADVANTAGE Combo is listed at $374.99. The price difference is minimal, but Makita undercuts DEWALT slightly. Value assessment depends on existing battery platforms. Users already invested in DEWALT 20V MAX or FLEXVOLT systems will find higher value in the DEWALT combo due to battery interchangeability. However, for new buyers seeking documented specifications and environmental protection at a slightly lower entry cost, the Makita kit presents a compelling value proposition with its included brushless efficiency claims.

Which one should you buy?

Choose the DEWALT FLEXVOLT ADVANTAGE Combo if you already own FLEXVOLT batteries and want to maximize power output through voltage scaling. The 6 Amp charger and superior LED brightness make it suitable for users prioritizing charging speed and visibility in dark spaces. Choose the Makita XT297T if you require documented torque specifications and lightweight tools for reduced fatigue. The XPT protection and brushless efficiency make it the better choice for harsh environments and users seeking longer run times per charge without upgrading battery voltage. Both kits offer professional-grade features, but your existing ecosystem and specific job site conditions should dictate the final decision.