EdgeStar BIDW1802SS vs Kenmore Elite 24" Built-In Dishwasher - UltraWash

Price Comparison

The EdgeStar BIDW1802SS is priced at $539.00, making it about 51% cheaper than the Kenmore Elite, which retails for $1,099.99. When considering budget constraints, the EdgeStar offers a more economical choice for consumers looking for a built-in dishwasher. This significant price gap may appeal to those who require essential features without breaking the bank. However, the Kenmore Elite's higher price reflects its advanced features and capacity, which may justify the investment for those seeking a more robust appliance.

Capacity and Size

The Kenmore Elite can accommodate up to 15 place settings, while the EdgeStar is designed for 8 place settings. This difference is substantial, making the Kenmore a better choice for larger households or those who frequently entertain guests. The increased capacity of the Kenmore Elite allows for more efficient dishwashing sessions, reducing the number of loads needed. Additionally, the EdgeStar's compact size, at only 17.75 inches wide, makes it ideal for smaller kitchens or spaces where a full-sized unit would not fit.

Cleaning Power

Cleaning efficiency differs notably between the two dishwashers. The Kenmore Elite features UltraWash Plus Power Cleaning, utilizing three pressurized spray arms to ensure thorough cleaning from all angles. This system is complemented by SmartWash technology, which automatically adjusts water temperature and pressure based on soil levels. In contrast, the EdgeStar offers six wash cycles, including Heavy and Normal modes, but lacks the advanced sensor technology found in the Kenmore. For those prioritizing cleaning performance, the Kenmore's features provide a significant edge.

Drying Performance

When it comes to drying capabilities, the Kenmore Elite outshines the EdgeStar. The Kenmore's TurboDry technology employs a built-in fan and heating element, ensuring that even plastic items come out dry and spot-free. This is particularly beneficial for users who want to eliminate the need for towel drying. The EdgeStar, while it includes a heated dry option, does not specify enhanced drying technologies, which may leave dishes less dry compared to the Kenmore. For users who prioritize dry dishes straight out of the dishwasher, the Kenmore is the superior choice.

Noise Level

The Kenmore Elite operates at a remarkably quiet 42 dBA, making it one of the quietest models available. This feature is advantageous for households that prefer a peaceful environment while running the dishwasher. In comparison, the EdgeStar has a noise level of 52 dBA, which, while not excessively loud, is noticeably noisier than the Kenmore. If noise reduction during operation is a key factor, the Kenmore Elite's quieter performance will likely appeal to consumers.

Design and Features

The design elements of the Kenmore Elite are more advanced than those of the EdgeStar. The Kenmore features a modern reach-thru bar handle, hidden touch controls, and interior LED lighting, which enhance usability and aesthetics. Additionally, it includes a TurboFlex third rack that adds 35% more space for utensils and small items, making organization easier. The EdgeStar, while functional, lacks these aesthetic and practical enhancements, presenting a more basic design. For consumers looking for a stylish and feature-rich dishwasher, the Kenmore Elite stands out.

Energy Efficiency

Both dishwashers are ENERGY STAR certified, indicating that they meet energy efficiency guidelines set by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. However, the Kenmore Elite's advanced features, like SmartWash technology, may contribute to more efficient washing cycles compared to the EdgeStar. While the EdgeStar is a cost-effective option in terms of initial price, the long-term energy savings of the Kenmore's features could make it a more economical choice over time for users who wash dishes frequently.

Which should you buy?

Choosing between the EdgeStar BIDW1802SS and the Kenmore Elite ultimately depends on your specific needs and budget. If you are looking for an economical option that fits small spaces and handles basic dishwashing tasks, the EdgeStar is a solid choice at $539. However, if you require a larger capacity, advanced cleaning and drying features, and a quieter operation, the Kenmore Elite, despite its higher price of $1,099.99, offers significant benefits that may justify the investment. For larger families or those who value performance and design, the Kenmore Elite is the better option.