EdgeStar BIDW1802SS vs Fisher & Paykel Series 9 Contemporary Double DishDrawer

Overview of the EdgeStar BIDW1802SS

The EdgeStar BIDW1802SS is an 18-inch wide built-in dishwasher designed for compact spaces and efficiency. Priced at $539.00, it is the more budget-friendly option compared to its counterpart, the Series 9 Contemporary Double DishDrawer Dishwasher. This model can accommodate up to eight place settings, making it a practical choice for small families or individuals living in apartments.

One of the standout features of the EdgeStar BIDW1802SS is its six wash cycles, which include heavy, normal, ECO, glass, rapid, and rinse. Additionally, it offers three options for enhanced cleaning, such as sanitize, hi temp, and heated dry. With a quiet operation at 52dB, this dishwasher is ideal for minimizing noise disturbances in your home.

Overview of the Series 9 Contemporary Double DishDrawer Dishwasher

The Series 9 Contemporary Double DishDrawer Dishwasher by Fisher & Paykel is a premium model priced at $2,249.00, making it significantly more expensive than the EdgeStar BIDW1802SS. This model features two independent drawers, allowing for simultaneous washing of two separate loads, which is a unique advantage for users with varying dishwashing needs.

Each drawer can wash half a load, making the Series 9 particularly efficient for smaller loads without the need to run a full dishwasher cycle. It has six wash programs, including quick wash, sanitize, and extra dry options, making it versatile for different types of dishes, from fine glassware to large pots. The ADA compliance of this model means it can be positioned at a convenient height for easy loading and unloading.

Price Comparison

When it comes to pricing, the EdgeStar BIDW1802SS is about 76% cheaper than the Series 9 Contemporary Double DishDrawer Dishwasher, with a price difference of $1,710.00. The EdgeStar is priced at $539.00, while the Fisher & Paykel model comes in at $2,249.00. This substantial price difference makes the EdgeStar an attractive option for budget-conscious consumers who still want effective dishwashing capabilities.

Despite being the more economical choice, the EdgeStar does not compromise on essential features. It still offers six wash cycles and a compact design, making it suitable for smaller kitchens. On the other hand, the premium price of the Series 9 reflects its advanced features and dual-drawer functionality, which may be worth the investment for users who frequently entertain or have larger dishwashing needs.

Design and Size

The EdgeStar BIDW1802SS is designed with compact spaces in mind, measuring 17.75 inches wide, making it suitable for installations where space is limited. Its dimensions allow it to replace older appliances, like a trash compactor, without requiring significant modifications to existing cabinetry.

In contrast, the Series 9 Contemporary Double DishDrawer Dishwasher has a more robust design with two large independent drawers, allowing for flexibility in loading. The accessible design is ADA compliant, making it easier to use for individuals of varying heights. While the EdgeStar is more compact, the Fisher & Paykel model's design caters to a different demographic, emphasizing ease of access and versatility.

Cleaning Efficiency

Both dishwashers excel in cleaning efficiency, but they cater to different cleaning needs. The EdgeStar BIDW1802SS features six wash cycles, including a specific setting for glassware, which is ideal for those who frequently wash delicate items. The presence of a leakage sensor is another benefit, ensuring that water flow is automatically shut off if a leak is detected, protecting your home from potential damage.

The Series 9 Contemporary Double DishDrawer Dishwasher stands out with its dual drawers, allowing users to run half loads independently. This feature not only conserves water and energy but also provides the ability to run different washing programs simultaneously. With its robust cleaning capabilities and specialized wash settings, this model is designed for those who value efficiency and versatility in their dishwashing routine.

Noise Level

Noise levels can significantly affect user experience, especially in open-plan living spaces. The EdgeStar BIDW1802SS operates at a quiet 52dB, which is a reasonable level for a dishwasher, ensuring that it won't disturb conversations or other activities in your home.

On the other hand, while specific noise levels for the Series 9 Contemporary Double DishDrawer Dishwasher are not provided, premium models typically focus on quieter operations. Given its higher price point, one can reasonably expect it to perform similarly or better in terms of reducing noise during operation, though specific figures would provide a clearer comparison.

User Experience and Ease of Use

The EdgeStar BIDW1802SS is user-friendly, designed for straightforward operation with its simple controls and accessible layout. The compact size and lightweight design (52.9 lbs) make installation and use a hassle-free experience.

Conversely, the Series 9 Contemporary Double DishDrawer Dishwasher enhances user experience with its innovative design. The independent drawers are as easy to open and close as standard kitchen cabinet drawers, promoting ease of loading and unloading. This focus on functionality, combined with its advanced wash programs, makes it an appealing choice for those who prioritize convenience and modern design.

Which should you buy?

Choosing between the EdgeStar BIDW1802SS and the Series 9 Contemporary Double DishDrawer Dishwasher ultimately depends on your specific needs and budget. If you're looking for a compact, efficient, and budget-friendly option, the EdgeStar BIDW1802SS at $539.00 is an excellent choice. It provides essential features and quiet operation, making it suitable for small households.

In contrast, if you frequently wash large loads or prefer the convenience of dual drawers, the Series 9 Contemporary Double DishDrawer Dishwasher offers advanced features and flexibility at a higher price point of $2,249.00. For those who value efficiency and modern design, this model may justify the investment. Ultimately, assess your dishwashing habits, kitchen space, and budget to make the best decision for your home.