EdgeStar BIDW1802SS vs Sharp SDW6736MS 24-inch Stainless Steel

Design and Build Quality

The EdgeStar BIDW1802SS features a compact 18-inch design, making it suitable for smaller kitchens, while the Sharp SDW6736MS boasts a more spacious 24-inch build. The EdgeStar is priced at $539.00, making it about 7% cheaper than the Sharp, which costs $579.00. Both dishwashers are crafted from stainless steel, ensuring durability and a modern aesthetic. The EdgeStar accommodates up to eight place settings, while the Sharp can handle up to 14, offering a significant advantage for larger households or those who entertain frequently.

Noise Levels

When it comes to noise levels, the Sharp SDW6736MS operates at a remarkably quiet 47 dB, ideal for open-concept homes. In contrast, the EdgeStar operates at 52 dB, which is relatively quiet but may be noticeable in smaller spaces. The difference of 5 dB can be perceived as a significant enhancement in the user experience, especially during nighttime operation or in homes where peace and quiet are paramount.

Wash Performance

The Sharp SDW6736MS excels in wash performance, offering a specialized Power Wash sprayer that enhances cleaning for heavily soiled pots and pans. It features six wash cycles and seven options, allowing for greater customization based on the load's needs. The EdgeStar offers six wash cycles as well but lacks the dedicated Power Wash capability. Both models include energy-efficient options, but the Sharp’s Wash Zone feature allows for more sustainable operation by targeting smaller loads, making it a strong contender for eco-conscious consumers.

Features and Usability

The Sharp SDW6736MS comes equipped with an adjustable third rack, which provides additional flexibility for organizing flatware and utensils. This feature is particularly useful for maximizing space and improving efficiency. The EdgeStar does not have a third rack but includes a silverware basket and cup tray, which may suffice for smaller households. The EdgeStar’s dimensions allow it to replace older appliances like trash compactors easily, making it a versatile choice for certain kitchen layouts.

Energy Efficiency

Energy efficiency is crucial for modern appliances, and both dishwashers aim to reduce water and energy usage. The EdgeStar's compact size naturally leads to lower overall consumption, while the Sharp’s Wash Zone feature allows users to run smaller loads, conserving resources when full capacity isn't necessary. Both appliances include options for energy-saving cycles, but the Sharp’s advanced features may provide better performance with less environmental impact over time.

Price Comparison

The EdgeStar BIDW1802SS is priced at $539.00, making it about 7% cheaper than the Sharp SDW6736MS, which retails for $579.00. This price difference of $40 may sway budget-conscious consumers, particularly those with smaller kitchens who do not require the additional features of the Sharp model. However, the investment in the Sharp may be justified by its superior cleaning capabilities and added features, such as the third rack and quieter operation.

Brand Reputation and Sales Rank

Both EdgeStar and Sharp have established themselves as reputable brands in the appliance market. The EdgeStar BIDW1802SS has a bestseller rank of 657, while the Sharp SDW6736MS is slightly lower at 964. This ranking indicates that the EdgeStar is more popular among consumers, perhaps due to its compact size and affordability. However, brand loyalty and personal preference for features could also influence purchasing decisions.

Which should you buy?

Choosing between the EdgeStar BIDW1802SS and the Sharp SDW6736MS ultimately depends on your specific needs. If you have a smaller kitchen and prioritize affordability, the EdgeStar is a solid option at $539.00, especially for those who do not require extensive features. However, if you seek superior cleaning performance, quieter operation, and added versatility with an adjustable third rack, the Sharp at $579.00 may be worth the extra investment. Consider your household size, frequency of use, and specific cleaning needs to make the best decision for your kitchen.