EdgeStar BIDW1802SS vs Whirlpool 24" 57dB Built-In Dishwasher - White

Design and Size

The EdgeStar BIDW1802SS is a compact unit at only 17.75 inches wide, while the Whirlpool 24" Built-In Dishwasher offers a full-size design. The EdgeStar is ideal for smaller kitchens or as a replacement for appliances like trash compactors. In contrast, the Whirlpool is designed to fit standard kitchen cabinets, making it suitable for a broader range of kitchen designs. The difference in dimensions reflects the intended use, with the EdgeStar accommodating up to eight place settings and the Whirlpool designed for larger loads, which can make a significant difference for bigger households.

Noise Level

The EdgeStar operates at a quiet 52 dB, making it a good choice for homes where noise is a concern. The Whirlpool, while slightly louder at 57 dB, is still marketed as a quiet operation dishwasher. The 5 dB difference may not seem substantial, but it can be perceptible in a quiet home setting. If peace during wash cycles is a priority, the EdgeStar might have a slight edge, but both models are designed to minimize disruptions during operation.

Wash Cycles and Options

EdgeStar features six wash cycles including Heavy, Normal, ECO, Glass, Rapid, and Rinse, along with three options: Sanitize, Hi Temp, and Heated Dry. This variety allows for tailored washing based on the level of soiling and the type of dishes. The Whirlpool offers a Boost Cycle for tackling tough messes and a Quick Wash Cycle, which is useful for handling smaller loads in less time. While both machines have features that cater to different needs, the EdgeStar’s broader range of cycles may offer more versatility for users with diverse dishwashing requirements.

Drying Performance

The EdgeStar includes a Heated Dry option, which enhances drying efficiency, while the Whirlpool emphasizes its Extended Dry Option for similar results. Both models strive to ensure dishes come out dry and ready to use, but the EdgeStar’s additional feature may provide an edge in terms of drying effectiveness. Ultimately, users may find that the effectiveness of drying is influenced by the cycle chosen and the types of dishes washed.

Energy Efficiency

The Whirlpool is Energy Star Certified, indicating it meets strict energy efficiency guidelines. This certification suggests that it saves energy and water with each wash, which could lead to lower utility bills over time. The EdgeStar does not mention Energy Star certification, which might mean it's less efficient in comparison. For environmentally conscious consumers, the Whirlpool's energy-saving features may be a significant selling point, especially considering the long-term savings on energy costs.

Build Quality and Durability

The EdgeStar features a silverware basket and cup tray, while the Whirlpool is built with a durable plastic tub that resists stains and retains heat efficiently. While both models aim for quality, the materials used in the Whirlpool might provide it with a longer lifespan in high-use situations. Consumers seeking durability may lean towards the Whirlpool, particularly in environments where the dishwasher is used frequently.

Price Comparison

The EdgeStar BIDW1802SS is priced at $539.00, whereas the Whirlpool is more budget-friendly at $399.00, making it about 26% cheaper. This price difference could be a deciding factor for many buyers. While the EdgeStar offers specific features that may justify its higher cost, the Whirlpool’s lower price point makes it an attractive option for those looking for basic functionality without breaking the bank.

Which should you buy?

Choosing between the EdgeStar BIDW1802SS and the Whirlpool 24" Built-In Dishwasher comes down to your specific needs and kitchen space. If you have limited space and require a compact unit with a variety of wash cycles, the EdgeStar could be the right fit for you. Conversely, if you prefer a full-sized dishwasher that offers energy efficiency and a lower price point, the Whirlpool stands out as a solid choice. Evaluate your household needs, budget, and kitchen layout to determine the best option for your dishwashing requirements.