Frigidaire 24 in. Top Control Built-in Tall Tub vs Sharp SDW4523MS 18-Inch Built-In Dishwasher,
Updated July 2026 — Frigidaire 24 in. Top Control Built-in Tall Tub leads on weight and width.
The Frigidaire offers a larger capacity and lower price, making it ideal for families, while the Sharp excels in quiet operation and modern features for compact spaces.
Why Frigidaire 24 in. Top Control Built-in Tall Tub is better
Price
Frigidaire is $320 cheaper than Sharp.
Capacity
Frigidaire holds 12 place settings compared to Sharp's 8.
Wash Cycles
Frigidaire offers 5 wash cycles versus Sharp's 6.
Why Sharp SDW4523MS 18-Inch Built-In Dishwasher, is better
Noise Level
Sharp operates at 47 dB, quieter than Frigidaire's 49 dB.
Compact Design
Sharp's 18-inch design is better for small kitchens.
Third Rack
Sharp includes a third rack for additional loading options.
Overall score
Specifications
| Spec | Frigidaire 24 in. Top Control Built-in Tall Tub | Sharp SDW4523MS 18-Inch Built-In Dishwasher, |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $479.00 | $799.00 |
| Wash Cycles | 5 | 6 |
| Energy Efficiency | Eco-Friendly | Smart Sensors |
| Control Type | Top Controls | Backlit Touch |
| Interior Material | Hybrid Stainless | Stainless Steel |
Dimension comparison
Introduction to the Frigidaire and Sharp Dishwashers
When comparing the Frigidaire 24 in. Top Control Built-in Dishwasher and the Sharp SDW4523MS 18-Inch Built-In Dishwasher, both offer unique advantages for different kitchen needs. The Frigidaire is priced at $479.00, making it about 17% cheaper than the Sharp, which retails for $799.00. While both models are designed to deliver effective cleaning, their features and capacities cater to distinct user preferences and kitchen sizes.
Design and Aesthetics
The Frigidaire features a spacious 24-inch design, which allows it to accommodate up to 12 place settings. Its stainless steel finish and integrated top controls provide a sleek look that blends well with modern kitchens. In contrast, the Sharp is more compact at 18 inches and offers a third rack, optimizing space for flatware and utensils. This design is particularly beneficial for smaller kitchens or apartments. Both dishwashers exhibit a contemporary aesthetic, but the choice between them largely depends on your kitchen size and layout.
Noise Level and Operation
The Frigidaire operates at a quiet 49 dB, making it suitable for everyday use without being disruptive. It features a hybrid stainless tub, enhancing its noise insulation. On the other hand, the Sharp boasts an even quieter operation at 47 dB, which is ideal for open-concept living spaces. Both models offer efficient cleaning while maintaining a peaceful kitchen environment, but if noise levels are a primary concern, the Sharp has a slight edge.
Capacity and Load Versatility
The Frigidaire can hold up to 12 place settings, making it a great choice for families or those who frequently entertain guests. It also offers five versatile wash cycles, including Heavy, Normal, and Quick, catering to various cleaning needs. Conversely, the Sharp, while smaller, can accommodate 8 place settings and features a third rack for additional loading options. It also includes six washing cycles, which provide flexibility for different cleaning scenarios. If you often have larger meals or gatherings, the Frigidaire's capacity may be more beneficial, while the Sharp is better for compact space efficiency.
Cleaning Features and Performance
The Frigidaire is equipped with a DishSense sensor that automatically adjusts water usage and cycle times for optimal cleaning results. Its Eco-Friendly Drying feature enhances energy efficiency, making it an environmentally friendly option. In comparison, the Sharp incorporates smart sensors in its Auto and Normal cycles, optimizing cleaning performance through intelligent adjustments. It also offers a Wash Zone option, allowing users to run either the upper or lower rack independently, which can save water and energy during smaller loads. Both models excel in their cleaning capabilities, but the additional versatility of the Sharp may appeal to users with varying dishwashing needs.
User Experience and Controls
The Frigidaire features integrated top controls with a front indicator for user-friendly operation. Its straightforward design caters to those who prefer simplicity in functionality. In contrast, the Sharp dishwasher includes backlit touch controls with adaptive indication, providing a modern touch to user interactions. This level of intuitiveness can enhance the overall user experience, especially for tech-savvy consumers. While both models are easy to operate, the Sharp's advanced controls may offer a more contemporary appeal.
Energy Efficiency
In terms of energy efficiency, both dishwashers are designed to minimize water and energy consumption. The Frigidaire's Eco-Friendly Drying feature contributes to its overall efficiency, while the Sharp's smart sensors optimize usage based on load size. While specific energy consumption figures are not provided, users can expect both models to align with modern energy standards. For those conscious of their environmental impact, both options present viable choices, but the Sharp’s Wash Zone feature may offer additional savings for smaller loads.
Which should you buy?
Choosing between the Frigidaire and the Sharp ultimately depends on your specific needs and kitchen dynamics. The Frigidaire is an excellent choice for larger households or those who frequently host gatherings, thanks to its higher capacity and competitive price of $479.00. However, if you reside in a compact space and value quiet operation and modern features, the Sharp, priced at $799.00, may be the better fit. Both dishwashers provide effective cleaning solutions, but your final decision should align with your lifestyle, kitchen size, and preferences.