HAOYUYAN Wireless Earbuds vs Soundcore P30i by Anker Noise Cancelling

Design and build quality

The physical construction of these earbuds reflects their intended use cases. The HAOYUYAN BX17 prioritizes durability for sports environments, featuring an IPX7 waterproof rating. This specification indicates protection against accidental submersion up to 1 meter for 30 minutes, making them suitable for intense training or outdoor adventures where rain and sweat are factors. The Soundcore P30i focuses on convenience with a unique 2-in-1 charging case that functions as a phone stand. While the water resistance rating is not explicitly specified for the Soundcore model, the case design offers utility for media consumption during travel. Both models utilize USB Type-C for charging, ensuring compatibility with modern cables.

Sound Quality and Drivers

Audio performance is driven by different hardware configurations in each model. The HAOYUYAN earbuds employ 14.3mm dynamic drivers, which are physically larger than the 10mm drivers found in the Soundcore P30i. Larger drivers often correlate with stronger bass response and air movement. However, the Soundcore P30i compensates for the smaller driver size with proprietary BassUp technology, designed to amplify low frequencies for a robust audio experience. The HAOYUYAN model relies on advanced acoustic tuning to deliver balanced mids and crisp highs. Users prioritizing raw driver size may lean towards the HAOYUYAN, while those preferring tuned bass enhancement might prefer the Soundcore.

Noise Cancelling Capabilities

This category reveals the most significant functional divergence between the two products. The Soundcore P30i is equipped with an advanced active noise cancelling (ANC) system capable of reducing external noise by up to 42dB. It includes adaptive technology that detects external sound levels and automatically selects an optimized cancellation level. Additionally, it offers a Transparency Mode to let ambient sound in when necessary. In contrast, the HAOYUYAN BX17 relies on passive noise isolation provided by its ergonomic design and silicone tips. While passive isolation can block some ambient noise, it lacks the active electronic countermeasures found in the Soundcore model, making the P30i superior for noisy commutes or flights.

Comfort and Fit

Comfort is subjective but heavily influenced by the physical design features listed in the specifications. The HAOYUYAN BX17 features flexible ear hooks and comes with three sizes of silicone tips. This design is explicitly intended for a secure, personalized fit during extended workouts and running. The ear hooks help prevent the earbuds from falling out during vigorous movement. The Soundcore P30i utilizes a standard in-ear design without mentioned ear hooks. While likely comfortable for general use, the HAOYUYAN model holds an advantage for users engaged in sports who require extra security to keep the earbuds in place during physical activity.

Battery life and efficiency

Battery specifications highlight a clear trade-off between longevity and feature usage. The HAOYUYAN BX17 claims a total playtime of 80 hours, which is significantly higher than the Soundcore P30i's total of 45 hours. The HAOYUYAN case recharges in 1.5 hours via USB-C. The Soundcore P30i offers up to 10 hours of playtime on a single charge, dropping to 6 hours when active noise cancelling is enabled. With the case, the Soundcore provides up to 25 hours with ANC active. While the Soundcore offers respectable battery life, the HAOYUYAN model provides nearly double the total usage time, reducing the frequency of case recharges for users who prioritize longevity over ANC features.

Connectivity and Controls

Interaction methods differ between the two devices. The HAOYUYAN BX17 features intuitive physical buttons on the earbuds themselves. These controls allow users to adjust volume, skip tracks, answer calls, and activate voice assistants without touching their phone. This tactile approach is beneficial for users with sweaty or gloved hands during workouts. The Soundcore P30i specifications do not explicitly detail the control mechanism, though the case features a back panel that opens to become a phone stand for hands-free viewing. The physical buttons on the HAOYUYAN model provide a distinct advantage for direct control accessibility during exercise.

Price and value

When evaluating cost against features, both earbuds occupy the budget-friendly segment. The HAOYUYAN BX17 is priced at $24.98, making it the more affordable option by a small margin. It offers high battery life and water resistance at this price point. The Soundcore P30i is priced at $27.99, costing slightly more but delivering active noise cancelling and transparency mode, features often found in more expensive tiers. The value proposition depends on user priority: the HAOYUYAN offers better raw specs for battery and durability per dollar, while the Soundcore offers advanced audio processing technology for a marginal price increase.

Which one should you buy?

Choosing between these models depends on your primary usage environment. If you require active noise cancellation for commuting or working in noisy environments, the Soundcore P30i is the better choice due to its 42dB reduction capability and transparency mode. The case stand also adds value for travelers who watch media on their phones. However, if you are an athlete or prioritize battery longevity, the HAOYUYAN BX17 is the superior option. Its IPX7 waterproof rating, secure ear hooks, and 80-hour total battery life make it ideal for rigorous physical activity where charging opportunities are scarce and durability is paramount.