LCDOLED Replacement 17.3 inches FHD vs LCDOLED® Compatible with ASUS TUF Gaming

Design and build quality

Both products are manufactured by LCDOLED and serve as replacement LCD screens for specific laptop models. As internal components, the physical build is designed to fit within the chassis of the respective laptops rather than stand alone as external monitors. The packaging for both units includes the LCD screen only, with no additional parts such as bezels or cables included. Users are advised to keep their original parts during installation. Both items undergo testing before shipping to ensure functionality, though specific build materials beyond the panel type are not detailed in the provided specifications. The focus remains on compatibility and panel performance rather than external aesthetics.

Display Size and Resolution

Product A features a 17.3-inch display size, which provides a larger viewing area compared to Product B's 15.6-inch panel. This difference is significant for users who prioritize screen real estate for multitasking or media consumption. Despite the size difference, both screens share the same resolution of 1920x1080 pixels. This means Product A has a lower pixel density due to the larger screen, while Product B offers a sharper image relative to its size. Both resolutions are standard Full HD, suitable for general computing and gaming tasks within the context of laptop replacements.

Refresh Rate and Performance

The refresh rate is a critical differentiator between these two panels. Product A operates at a 60Hz refresh rate and is explicitly noted as not suitable for 144Hz setups. In contrast, Product B supports a 120Hz refresh rate and is compatible with 144Hz configurations, though it is not designed for 60Hz systems. This makes Product B significantly better for gaming scenarios where motion clarity and smoothness are prioritized. The higher refresh rate on Product B allows for more frames per second to be displayed, reducing motion blur during fast-paced activities. Users must check their PC refresh rate settings before purchasing to ensure compatibility.

Panel Technology and Color

Both replacement screens utilize IPS panel technology, which generally offers better viewing angles and color consistency compared to TN panels. The color gamut for both Product A and Product B is listed at 72% NTSC. This indicates a similar level of color reproduction capability suitable for standard content consumption and casual creative work. Neither product specifies HDR support or peak brightness levels in the provided data. The backlight technology for both units is LED LCD, ensuring standard power efficiency and brightness levels typical for laptop replacements in this category.

Connectivity and Connector Pins

Connectivity differs substantially between the two options due to the specific laptop models they support. Product A uses an EDP 30-pin connector, which is standard for many 60Hz panels. Product B utilizes an EDP 40-pin connector, which is necessary to support the higher bandwidth required for 120Hz refresh rates. Users cannot interchange these connectors; a 30-pin cable will not fit a 40-pin screen and vice versa. It is crucial for buyers to verify the pin count of their original LCD connector before purchase to avoid compatibility issues during installation.

Compatibility and Model Support

Product A is designed specifically for Lenovo Legion Y540-17IRH series laptops, including model numbers like 81Q4 and 81T3. Product B targets the ASUS TUF Gaming FX505 series, including variants like FX505DT and FX505DV. The manufacturer notes that even for the same product, the model may change as production lots change, and compatible models may be sent randomly unless confirmed beforehand. This variability requires users to be vigilant about matching their specific laptop model number with the replacement screen. Neither screen is universally compatible across different brands due to physical and electrical differences.

Price and Value

Product B is priced at $89.98, which is lower than Product A's price of $92.98. Considering Product B also offers a higher refresh rate of 120Hz compared to Product A's 60Hz, it presents a stronger value proposition for gamers. Product A commands a slightly higher price likely due to the larger 17.3-inch panel size, which involves more material costs. Both products come with the assurance of pre-shipping testing. For users replacing a broken screen, the value depends heavily on whether they need the larger size of Product A or the performance benefits of Product B.

Which one should you buy?

The choice between these two LCDOLED replacement screens depends primarily on your laptop model and performance needs. If you own a Lenovo Legion Y540-17IRH and require a 17.3-inch display, Product A is the necessary choice despite the lower refresh rate. However, if you own an ASUS TUF Gaming FX505 series laptop, Product B is the required compatibility match. For users prioritizing gaming performance, Product B is the superior option due to its 120Hz refresh rate and lower price. Always verify your connector pin count and refresh rate settings before ordering to ensure the replacement functions correctly.