Makita XSR01Z 36V LXT® Brushless Rear Handle vs SKIL 2x20V PWR CORE 20 Brushless 7-1/4” Rear

Price Comparison

When it comes to price, the Makita XSR01Z is about 13% cheaper than the SKIL circular saw. The Makita XSR01Z is priced at $241.65, while the SKIL 2x20V PWR CORE 20 is priced at $279.00. This price difference of $37.35 may influence budget-conscious buyers looking for a high-quality circular saw. Despite the higher price tag, the SKIL saw offers additional features that might justify the extra cost for some users.

Power and Performance

The SKIL circular saw boasts a slightly higher maximum RPM of 5,300 compared to the Makita's 5,100 RPM. This difference may provide the SKIL saw with a slight edge in cutting speed, particularly for tougher materials. Additionally, the SKIL saw claims to deliver up to 600 cuts per charge in 2x4 lumber, while the Makita can make up to 558 cuts using two 5.0Ah batteries. This performance difference could be crucial for users needing maximum output in demanding situations.

Battery and Runtime

Both saws utilize lithium-ion batteries, but they differ in their technology and charging capabilities. The Makita XSR01Z operates on two 18V LXT batteries, while the SKIL circular saw uses two 20V PWR CORE 20 batteries. Notably, the SKIL kit includes two 5.0Ah batteries and a dual-port charger that can recharge the batteries from 0% to 25% in just 15 minutes. In contrast, the Makita saw requires users to purchase batteries separately and does not specify a quick charging feature, which could lead to longer downtimes between uses.

Design and Ergonomics

In terms of design, both saws have a rear handle configuration that enhances user comfort and control during operation. The Makita XSR01Z weighs 12.4 lbs with batteries, while the weight of the SKIL circular saw is not explicitly stated but is designed to be manageable for prolonged use. The Makita’s blade-left rear-handle design may appeal to users accustomed to corded saws, while the SKIL saw features an adaptable dust port to help keep the workspace clean. These ergonomic considerations may influence user preference based on individual comfort and usability needs.

Cutting Capacity

Both saws have a cutting depth of 2-9/16 inches, allowing them to cut through 3X lumber in a single pass. This similarity in cutting capacity ensures that both models are well-equipped for a range of cutting tasks. However, the SKIL circular saw's brushless motor is designed for intelligent power management, which may enhance its overall cutting efficiency and effectiveness, particularly in demanding applications. This could be a deciding factor for professionals who frequently work with thick materials.

Additional Features

The SKIL saw comes with several additional features that enhance its usability. It includes an LED light for improved visibility in low-light conditions and a built-in rafter hook for easy storage. The Makita XSR01Z, while lacking these specific features, offers the advantage of Star Protection Computer Controls, which help protect against overloading, over-discharging, and overheating. This technology could potentially extend the tool's lifespan and reliability, making it a strong contender for frequent users.

Customer Reception

In terms of customer reception, the Makita XSR01Z has a bestseller rank of 30,684, indicating a solid market presence and positive reception among users. Conversely, the SKIL circular saw has a higher bestseller rank of 149,900, suggesting it may not be as widely favored or recognized as the Makita model. This difference in sales rank may reflect user satisfaction and brand loyalty, with the Makita brand generally being well-regarded in the power tool market.

Which should you buy?

Ultimately, the decision between the Makita XSR01Z and the SKIL 2x20V PWR CORE 20 will depend on individual needs and preferences. The Makita XSR01Z is the more budget-friendly option, offering reliable performance and advanced motor technology. On the other hand, the SKIL circular saw, while more expensive, provides additional features like quicker charging and superior cutting performance, which could justify the higher price for users who prioritize efficiency. Consider your specific requirements and budget to make the best choice for your circular saw needs.