Meike vs Tamron 17-

Overview

In this comparison, we will examine the Meike 85mm F1.8 SE Mark II STM AF lens and the Tamron 17-70mm f/2.8 Di III-A VC RXD lens. The Meike lens is priced at $229.99, making it about 61% cheaper than the Tamron lens, which retails for $599.00. This significant price difference sets the stage for a detailed look at their features, performance, and suitability for different photography needs.

Compatibility and Mounting

The Meike 85mm F1.8 SE Mark II is designed for Canon EF mount cameras, including popular models like the 5D, 6D, and Rebel series. This wide compatibility allows Canon users to easily integrate this lens into their existing camera systems. On the other hand, the Tamron 17-70mm lens is tailored for Sony E APS-C mirrorless cameras, boasting a versatile zoom range that is particularly beneficial for those who prefer shooting with Sony's mirrorless systems. The specific mounting options of each lens cater to different user bases, which can significantly influence a photographer’s choice based on their camera brand.

Focal Length and Aperture

The Meike lens features a standard 85mm focal length with a wide aperture of F1.8, ideal for portrait and architectural photography, providing beautiful bokeh effects due to its 11 diaphragm blades. In contrast, the Tamron lens offers a much broader focal length range of 17-70mm with a consistent maximum aperture of F2.8. This makes the Tamron lens more versatile for a variety of shooting situations, from landscapes to portraits. While the Meike is excellent for specialized portrait work, the Tamron lens excels in everyday photography scenarios due to its zoom capabilities.

Optical Performance

Optical performance is a key differentiator between these two lenses. The Meike lens is constructed with 11 elements in 7 groups, which supports high-resolution output, even up to 8K quality. This makes it a strong contender for photographers seeking sharpness and detail in their images. Meanwhile, the Tamron lens features 16 elements in 12 groups, including two Glass Molded Aspherical elements and one hybrid aspherical lens element, which enhances its optical performance significantly. The Tamron's design is particularly tailored for minimizing distortion and maintaining clarity throughout the zoom range, making it an excellent choice for videographers and those shooting in diverse conditions.

Autofocus and Usability

Autofocus capability is another important factor to consider. The Meike 85mm lens is equipped with an STM stepping motor that ensures silent and smooth focusing, enhancing the experience for portrait photographers who need to capture candid moments without noise. It also supports electronic aperture adjustment and EXIF information transmission, adding to its user-friendly features. Conversely, the Tamron lens boasts advanced Vibration Compensation (VC) technology, making it ideal for handheld shooting, especially in low-light situations. The close focusing capability of the Tamron, with a minimum object distance of just 7.5 inches at 17mm, allows for impressive macro-style shots, which can be a game changer for creative photography.

Build Quality and Design

When it comes to build quality, the Tamron lens stands out with its moisture-resistant construction and fluorine coating, making it more durable and suitable for outdoor photography in various weather conditions. This is particularly beneficial for photographers who often shoot in unpredictable environments. The Meike 85mm lens, while well-constructed, does not specify any moisture resistance features, which could be a consideration for users who require robustness in their gear. The design philosophy behind each lens reflects the intended usage scenarios, with the Tamron focusing on versatility and durability.

Price and Value

The Meike 85mm lens, priced at $229.99, offers substantial value, especially for photographers who specialize in portraiture. Its affordability makes it an attractive option for those starting in photography or looking to expand their lens collection without breaking the bank. In contrast, the Tamron lens, at $599.00, is a more significant investment but justifies its price through versatility and optical quality. The difference of about $369 between the two lenses may lead some photographers to weigh their specific needs against their budgets, ultimately influencing their choice.

Which should you buy?

Choosing between the Meike 85mm F1.8 SE Mark II and the Tamron 17-70mm f/2.8 lens comes down to your photographic needs and equipment compatibility. If you are a Canon user seeking a high-quality portrait lens that excels in low light, the Meike lens offers excellent value at $229.99. However, if you are a Sony APS-C mirrorless camera user looking for a versatile zoom lens suitable for a variety of shooting conditions, the Tamron lens, despite its higher price of $599.00, provides superior performance and adaptability. Ultimately, your specific requirements will dictate which lens is the better choice for you.