Nikon AF-S DX NIKKOR 55- vs Nikon NIKKOR Z 28-

Overview

When comparing the Nikon AF-S DX NIKKOR 55-300mm f/4.5-5.6G ED Vibration Reduction Zoom Lens and the Nikon NIKKOR Z 28-400mm f/4-8 VR Mirrorless Lens, significant differences in features and pricing emerge. The former is priced at $359.95, while the latter comes in at $1,296.95, making the Nikon NIKKOR Z lens about 260% more expensive. This article will explore various aspects of these two lenses to help you decide which one better suits your photography needs.

Focal Length and Zoom Capabilities

The Nikon NIKKOR Z offers a broader focal length range than the Nikon AF-S DX. With a range of 28mm to 400mm, the NIKKOR Z lens provides a 14.2x zoom capability. In contrast, the AF-S DX lens covers a focal length range of 55mm to 300mm, offering a 5.5x zoom. This means the NIKKOR Z lens can capture wider shots while still providing ample telephoto reach, making it more versatile for various shooting scenarios, from landscapes to wildlife photography.

Image Stabilization Technology

Both lenses feature advanced image stabilization, but their effectiveness is rated differently. The Nikon AF-S DX model includes Nikon's VR II image stabilization, which is effective in reducing blurriness during handheld shooting. Meanwhile, the NIKKOR Z lens boasts stable VR performance equivalent to a 5.0-stop increase in shutter speed, which can be enhanced to a 5.5-stop stabilization when paired with compatible cameras. This makes the NIKKOR Z lens potentially superior for shooting in low-light conditions or when capturing fast-moving subjects.

Autofocus System

The autofocus systems in both lenses are designed to enhance shooting efficiency. The Nikon AF-S DX lens features an exclusive Silent Wave Motor (SWM), which ensures quick and quiet focusing—a critical aspect for wildlife and event photography. The NIKKOR Z lens supports a linear MF drive that enables smooth focusing, particularly beneficial for video shooting. While both systems are effective, the choice may depend on whether you prioritize still photography or video capabilities.

Weight and Portability

Portability is a vital factor for photographers on the move. The Nikon NIKKOR Z weighs approximately 1.6 lbs (725 g), making it the lightest lens in its class and a more comfortable option for extended shooting sessions. In comparison, the weight of the Nikon AF-S DX is not specified, but it is generally known to be heavier than its mirrorless counterparts. If you plan to travel or shoot for prolonged periods, the NIKKOR Z lens may offer the advantage of easier handling.

Minimum Focus Distance

The minimum focus distance is crucial for achieving close-up shots. The Nikon NIKKOR Z allows for a minimum focus distance of just 0.2 m at the maximum wide-angle position, which is significantly shorter than the minimum focus distance of 4.6 ft (1.4 m) for the Nikon AF-S DX lens. This feature enables the NIKKOR Z lens to capture more intimate details and dynamic expressions, making it particularly suited for macro photography and creative compositions.

Price Comparison

The price difference between the two lenses is substantial. The Nikon AF-S DX is priced at $359.95, whereas the NIKKOR Z retails for $1,296.95. This means the NIKKOR Z is about $936 more expensive than the AF-S DX lens, which may be a deciding factor for photographers on a budget. While the NIKKOR Z offers advanced features and versatility, the AF-S DX provides excellent value for those who primarily shoot with Nikon DSLR cameras.

User Experience and Versatility

In terms of user experience, the NIKKOR Z lens excels in versatility with its extensive zoom range and lightweight design, making it suitable for a variety of settings, including sports, travel, and wildlife photography. The Nikon AF-S DX lens, while slightly limited in its zoom capabilities, remains a solid choice for photographers who prefer a more traditional DSLR setup and need a reliable telephoto option.

Which should you buy?

Deciding between the Nikon AF-S DX NIKKOR 55-300mm and the Nikon NIKKOR Z 28-400mm ultimately comes down to your specific needs and budget. If you are looking for a cost-effective option that still provides good performance, the AF-S DX lens is a solid choice at $359.95. However, if your photography requires a broader focal range, superior image stabilization, and lightweight portability, the NIKKOR Z lens may justify its price tag of $1,296.95 for serious enthusiasts and professionals alike. Each lens has its strengths, so weigh your priorities carefully before making a decision.