Samson DK705 Drum Mic 5-piece Kit vs Shure PG ALTA 7-Piece Drum Microphone Kit for

Introduction to the Kits

When it comes to miking a drum kit, the choice between the Samson DK705 Drum Mic 5-piece Kit and the Shure PG ALTA 7-Piece Drum Microphone Kit is crucial for achieving optimal sound quality. The Samson kit is priced at $219.99, making it about 67% cheaper than the Shure kit, which costs $659.00. This significant price difference raises the question of whether the more economical option can deliver satisfactory performance or if the higher investment in the Shure kit is justified.

Components Included

The Samson DK705 includes five microphones designed specifically for a standard 5-piece drum kit. This kit comes with a Q71 dynamic kick drum mic and four Q72 dynamic microphones for toms and snare. In comparison, the Shure PG ALTA offers seven microphones, including a PGA52 for kick drums, three PGA56 mics for snare and toms, a PGA57 for instruments, and two PGA81 condenser mics for versatile applications. While the Samson kit is streamlined for standard setups, the Shure kit provides a broader range of options that may be beneficial for drummers looking to mic additional instruments or cymbals.

Target Audience

The Samson DK705 is ideal for beginner to intermediate drummers who need a straightforward, no-frills solution for capturing their sound. The kit's design focuses on high SPL handling, making it suitable for various drumming styles. Conversely, the Shure PG ALTA kit targets professional drummers and sound engineers who require top-quality microphones for performances and recordings. Its inclusion of a wider variety of microphones allows for more nuanced sound capturing, benefiting those with more complex setups.

Performance and Sound Quality

Both kits are engineered to handle high sound pressure levels (SPL), which is crucial for drummers who play at high volumes. The Samson DK705 features microphones that are tailored for low-end capture, particularly the Q71, designed to record the punchy attack of a bass drum. The Shure PG ALTA, with its PGA52 kick drum mic and multiple dynamic and condenser options, offers a more versatile approach to sound quality, capable of capturing a wider frequency range. The Shure kit's emphasis on professional-grade microphones suggests a higher quality of sound reproduction, which may appeal to those prioritizing studio-quality recordings.

Ease of Setup and Portability

The Samson DK705 excels in ease of setup, coming with all necessary mounting hardware and a hardshell carry case for protection and transport. This makes it an attractive option for drummers who frequently move between venues. The Shure PG ALTA kit also comes with a carrying case and includes seven XLR cables and three drum mounts, but the additional components may require a more time-consuming setup process. Drummers seeking simplicity and speed might lean towards the Samson kit, while those willing to invest extra time for potentially superior sound may prefer the Shure option.

Price Comparison

The price difference between the two kits is substantial, with the Samson DK705 retailing at $219.99 and the Shure PG ALTA priced at $659.00. This means that the Samson kit is approximately $439 cheaper, making it a more budget-friendly option. However, the higher price of the Shure kit reflects its additional components and potential for higher sound fidelity, which may be worth the investment for serious musicians or recording professionals.

Bestseller Ranking

In terms of sales performance, the Samson DK705 holds a sales rank of 64,072, while the Shure PG ALTA boasts a better rank of 22,556. This indicates that the Shure kit is more popular among consumers, possibly due to its reputation for quality and professional use. Higher sales rankings can suggest better user satisfaction, but it’s essential to consider the specific needs and preferences of the buyer when interpreting these figures.

Which should you buy?

Ultimately, the choice between the Samson DK705 Drum Mic 5-piece Kit and the Shure PG ALTA 7-Piece Drum Microphone Kit depends on your specific needs as a drummer. If you're a beginner or on a budget, the Samson kit provides excellent value with its focused design and ease of setup. However, for those looking for a more comprehensive solution with higher sound quality and versatility, the Shure PG ALTA is undoubtedly worth the investment. Consider your drumming style, environment, and musical goals to make the best choice for your sound.