ASICS Women's Gel-Excite 11 Running Shoes, 8, Dark vs Under Armour Women's Charged Assert 9, Black/White, 8.5 US

Price Comparison

When comparing prices, the Under Armour Women's Charged Assert 9 is the more budget-friendly option at $57.95, making it about 22% cheaper than the ASICS Women's Gel-Excite 11, which retails for $74.95. This price difference can be significant for budget-conscious shoppers looking for quality running shoes without breaking the bank. The Charged Assert 9 not only offers savings but also maintains a solid reputation, as indicated by its bestseller rank of 2002, compared to the ASICS at 2352.

Comfort and Cushioning

The ASICS Women's Gel-Excite 11 features advanced FF BLAST PLUS cushioning, designed to provide a lightweight and responsive ride. In contrast, the Under Armour Women's Charged Assert 9 uses Charged Cushioning technology, which delivers balanced impact protection. Both shoes prioritize comfort, but the Gel-Excite 11 claims to offer a "cloud-like" experience, while the Charged Assert 9 focuses on a plush step-in feel. The ASICS shoe, featuring AMPLIFOAM PLUS technology, aims to offer a softer ride, which may appeal to runners looking for maximum comfort during longer runs.

Breathability and Upper Design

Breathability is crucial for running shoes, and both the ASICS and Under Armour models excel in this area. The ASICS Women's Gel-Excite 11 utilizes an engineered mesh upper that reduces the need for additional overlays, enhancing airflow. Meanwhile, the Under Armour Women's Charged Assert 9 also boasts a lightweight mesh upper designed to keep feet cool. Both designs contribute positively to comfort during warm-weather activities, but the emphasis on airflow in both shoes may cater to different preferences in fit and feel.

Stability and Support

Stability is an essential factor for runners, and the Under Armour Women's Charged Assert 9 stands out with its reinforced overlays that improve midfoot support. This feature helps keep the foot centered during strides, ideal for both light training and longer walks. The ASICS Women's Gel-Excite 11, while offering comfort, does not specifically highlight midfoot support features. Thus, those seeking additional stability in their running shoes may lean towards the Charged Assert 9, especially if they are new to running or prefer extra support.

Outsole and Traction

When it comes to traction, both shoes employ different technologies. The ASICS Women's Gel-Excite 11 features a FLUIDRIDE outsole, designed to create smoother strides, which can be particularly beneficial for a seamless running experience. In contrast, the Under Armour Women's Charged Assert 9 incorporates a rubber outsole with a flexible tread pattern to enhance traction and natural flexibility. This makes the Charged Assert 9 favorable for varied terrain, while the Gel-Excite 11 may excel on smoother surfaces.

Weight and Flexibility

Weight can greatly influence a runner's performance, and the Under Armour Women's Charged Assert 9 is engineered to be lightweight, which can enhance speed and agility. The ASICS Women's Gel-Excite 11, while also designed to be lightweight, focuses more on providing cushioning and comfort. While both shoes aim for a balance of comfort and performance, those prioritizing a lighter shoe may find the Charged Assert 9 more appealing, especially for speed-focused workouts or races.

Style and Aesthetics

Aesthetic appeal can play a significant role in a runner's choice of footwear. The ASICS Women's Gel-Excite 11 comes in a striking Dark Pink Clay/Orange Glow colorway, adding a vibrant touch for those who appreciate style in their sports gear. On the other hand, the Under Armour Women's Charged Assert 9 features a classic Black/White combination, providing a more versatile look suitable for various outfits. Depending on personal style preferences, either shoe could be a great addition to a runner's wardrobe, though the ASICS may attract those looking for a bolder statement.

Which should you buy?

Deciding between the ASICS Women's Gel-Excite 11 and the Under Armour Women's Charged Assert 9 ultimately depends on what you value most in a running shoe. If you prioritize cushioning and comfort, the ASICS may be the better choice, despite its higher price. However, if affordability, stability, and a lightweight feel are more important to you, the Under Armour option is about 22% cheaper and provides excellent support for new runners. Each shoe has its unique advantages, making either a solid choice based on personal preferences and running needs.