Brooks Women’s Ghost 17 Neutral Running Shoe - White/Black/Rose Gold - 8 Medium vs New Balance Women's Fresh Foam Arishi V4 Running Shoe, Summer Fog/Nimbus Cloud/Light Gold Metallic, 8

Price Comparison: Brooks Ghost 17 vs. New Balance Fresh Foam Arishi V4

The New Balance Fresh Foam Arishi V4 is about 50% cheaper than the Brooks Ghost 17, priced at $55.99 compared to $110.00. This significant price difference makes the New Balance model a compelling choice for budget-conscious buyers seeking performance without premium pricing. The Brooks Ghost 17 commands a higher price point, reflecting its advanced cushioning technology and certifications such as PDAC A5500 Diabetic Shoe and APMA Seal of Acceptance. While both shoes are available at competitive rates—New Balance averaging $57.73 over the past 90 days—the Ghost 17 consistently sells at nearly double that amount. For runners prioritizing cost efficiency, the New Balance offers more value per dollar spent.

Cushioning Technology: Softness and Support

The Brooks Ghost 17 features nitrogen-infused DNA LOFT v3 cushioning with an extra 1mm in the heel and 3mm in the forefoot, delivering lightweight softness and long-lasting comfort. This enhanced cushioning is specifically designed to make every mile feel as good as the first. In contrast, the New Balance Fresh Foam Arishi V4 uses a fresh foam midsole that provides responsive comfort with each step. While both offer cushioned rides, the Ghost 17’s upgraded material and additional thickness suggest a more plush experience, particularly on longer runs. The New Balance focuses on responsiveness rather than maximum softness, making it better suited for runners who prefer a firmer, more grounded feel.

Fit and Upper Construction

The Brooks Ghost 17 includes a double jacquard air mesh upper with a kick-back collar for support and structure, ensuring optimal airflow and a snug, adaptive fit. This design enhances breathability and helps feet stay cool and dry during intense activity. The New Balance Fresh Foam Arishi V4 uses a breathable mesh upper with no-sew construction, which reduces weight and improves durability. While both prioritize ventilation, the Ghost 17’s dual-layer mesh and structured collar provide more targeted support, especially around the ankle. The no-sew method in the New Balance minimizes bulk and contributes to a lighter overall shoe, ideal for those seeking minimalism and longevity.

Midsole Design and Transition Smoothness

The Brooks Ghost 17 incorporates precise flex grooves in its midsole to promote smooth transitions and natural toe-off, helping maintain speed and momentum throughout the stride. This innovation supports a fluid running motion, reducing fatigue over time. The New Balance Fresh Foam Arishi V4 lacks specific mention of flex grooves or transition-enhancing features, relying instead on its fresh foam midsole for general responsiveness. While both shoes aim to deliver a comfortable ride, the Ghost 17’s engineered midsole design gives it an edge in facilitating efficient movement, particularly for runners focused on form and consistency.

Outsole Durability and Traction

The Brooks Ghost 17 features an innovative rubber compound made with recycled silica, offering a balance of durability, lightweight performance, and responsive rebound across various terrains. This environmentally conscious material supports long-term wear while maintaining grip. The New Balance Fresh Foam Arishi V4 does not specify outsole composition or materials, but its durable construction is implied through the no-sew technique and emphasis on long-lasting wear. While the Ghost 17 explicitly highlights its sustainable, high-performance rubber, the New Balance’s outsole details remain unspecified, leaving its traction and longevity less defined by the provided data.

Brand Certifications and Special Features

The Brooks Ghost 17 holds multiple industry-recognized certifications: it is a certified PDAC A5500 Diabetic Shoe and has earned the APMA Seal of Acceptance. These endorsements validate its suitability for individuals with foot health concerns and underscore its commitment to medical-grade comfort and support. Additionally, the Ghost 17 is a certified carbon neutral product, appealing to environmentally conscious consumers. The New Balance Fresh Foam Arishi V4 does not list any similar certifications or medical endorsements. Its focus appears to be on everyday versatility and performance, without the added validation seen in the Brooks model.

Bestseller Rank and Market Positioning

The Brooks Ghost 17 ranks #61 in bestseller rank, indicating strong consumer demand and consistent popularity within the running shoe category. This high ranking reflects its reputation as a reliable, go-to daily trainer. The New Balance Fresh Foam Arishi V4 ranks #367, suggesting lower visibility or sales volume in comparison. Despite this, the New Balance maintains a solid presence with an average price of $57.73 over the past 90 days, showing steady interest. The Ghost 17’s superior ranking aligns with its premium positioning, while the New Balance competes effectively on value and accessibility.

Which should you buy?

Choose the Brooks Women’s Ghost 17 if you prioritize premium cushioning, medical certifications, and a proven track record of performance—especially if you’re a runner seeking long-term comfort and support. It’s ideal for daily training, walking, or travel, backed by APMA and PDAC recognition. However, if you're looking for a more affordable option with solid performance and lightweight durability, the New Balance Women's Fresh Foam Arishi V4 is about 50% cheaper at $55.99 and delivers responsive comfort with no-sew construction and breathable mesh. For budget-focused buyers or those wanting a versatile, low-maintenance shoe, the New Balance offers excellent value. Ultimately, the Ghost 17 justifies its higher price with advanced features and credibility; the Fresh Foam Arishi V4 wins on affordability and simplicity.