ASICS Women's Gel-Excite 11 Running Shoes, 8, Dark vs New Balance Women's Fresh Foam 680 V8 Running Shoe

Overview of ASICS Women's Gel-Excite 11 Running Shoes

The ASICS Women's Gel-Excite 11 Running Shoes are designed for comfort and versatility, featuring advanced cushioning technologies. Priced at $74.95, these shoes incorporate FF BLAST PLUS cushioning for a lighter, responsive ride and PureGEL technology for enhanced softness. With a sales rank of 2,352, they are a popular choice among runners. The engineered mesh upper promotes breathability, while the FLUIDRIDE outsole ensures smoother strides, making these shoes suitable for both running and fitness routines.

Overview of New Balance Women's Fresh Foam 680 V8 Running Shoe

The New Balance Women's Fresh Foam 680 V8 Running Shoe is a durable and comfortable option, priced at $69.99, making it about 7% cheaper than the ASICS model. It features Fresh Foam midsole cushioning, engineered for an ultra-cushioned experience. With a sales rank of 13,745, it caters to a broad audience needing a reliable shoe for everyday runs and workouts. The precision-engineered knit upper offers targeted ventilation, while the integrated rubber outsole enhances comfort with every step.

Cushioning and Comfort

When it comes to cushioning, both shoes offer impressive technologies, but they approach comfort differently. The ASICS Gel-Excite 11 utilizes FF BLAST PLUS and AMPLIFOAM PLUS cushioning, providing cloud-like comfort and a responsive ride. In contrast, the New Balance 680 V8 features a Fresh Foam midsole that is precision-engineered for lightweight cushioning with approximately 3% bio-based content. While the ASICS shoe may appeal to those prioritizing responsiveness, the New Balance model is particularly suitable for those who want an ultra-cushioned experience, ideal for longer runs.

Breathability and Fit

In terms of breathability, both shoes excel with their unique uppers. The ASICS Gel-Excite 11 features an engineered mesh upper, designed to be lightweight and breathable, reducing the need for additional overlays. The New Balance 680 V8, on the other hand, employs a precision-engineered knit upper that offers maximum comfort and targeted ventilation. While both models ensure proper airflow, the ASICS shoe may provide a slightly more traditional fit, whereas the New Balance’s no-sew construction offers a sleek, modern aesthetic.

Weight and Performance

Weight can significantly affect performance, especially during long runs or workouts. The ASICS Gel-Excite 11 is built to provide a lighter feel due to its FF BLAST PLUS cushioning and breathable upper, which enhances overall performance. Although the exact weight is not specified, the emphasis on lightweight materials suggests a focus on agility. The New Balance 680 V8, while also lightweight, focuses more on soft cushioning and comfort, which may appeal to everyday runners. Both shoes are designed to support performance but cater to different preferences in running style.

Durability and Build Quality

Durability is crucial for running shoes, and both models showcase solid build quality. The ASICS Gel-Excite 11 is layered with AMPLIFOAM PLUS technology for a soft, comfortable ride, while the FLUIDRIDE outsole contributes to durability and smoother strides. In contrast, the New Balance 680 V8 emphasizes a robust construction with its integrated rubber outsole designed for comfort in every step. Both shoes are tailored for long-term use, but the choice may depend on whether you lean toward cushioning or a sturdier build.

Price Comparison

Price is an essential consideration for many buyers. The ASICS Women's Gel-Excite 11 is priced at $74.95, while the New Balance Women's Fresh Foam 680 V8 is available for $69.99. This makes the New Balance model approximately $4.96 cheaper, or about 7% less expensive than the ASICS shoe. If budget is a primary factor in your decision, the New Balance option may present a more attractive choice without sacrificing comfort or performance.

Which should you buy?

Choosing between the ASICS Women's Gel-Excite 11 and the New Balance Women's Fresh Foam 680 V8 largely depends on your personal running style and preferences. If you prioritize responsiveness, breathability, and a slightly lighter shoe, the ASICS model may be the better fit. However, if comfort, cushioning, and a more budget-friendly option are your main concerns, the New Balance shoe stands out as a compelling choice. With both shoes offering unique benefits, your decision should align with what aspects of running footwear matter most to you.