ASICS Women's Gel-Excite 11 Running Shoes, 8, Dark vs Brooks Women’s Glycerin 23 Neutral Running Shoe -

Overview of ASICS Women's Gel-Excite 11 Running Shoes

The ASICS Women's Gel-Excite 11 Running Shoes are priced at $74.95 and are designed for comfort and versatility. With a sales rank of 2,352, these shoes feature FF BLAST PLUS cushioning, which provides cloud-like comfort while remaining lightweight. The shoe's engineered mesh upper promotes breathability, making it suitable for various fitness routines. Additionally, the FLUIDRIDE outsole enhances smooth strides, while AMPLIFOAM PLUS cushioning offers a softer ride compared to standard options. Overall, the Gel-Excite 11 aims to deliver a balanced combination of comfort and performance for runners.

Overview of Brooks Women’s Glycerin 23 Neutral Running Shoe

The Brooks Women’s Glycerin 23 Neutral Running Shoe is considerably more expensive at $159.99, reflecting its premium design aimed at neutral runners. With a sales rank of 4,982, this shoe is crafted for long runs and daily training, boasting a luxurious feel due to its zonal DNA tuned cushioning. This adaptive foam offers a plush ride while supporting consistent performance, particularly for high-mileage runners. The shoe also features a breathable engineered upper for a secure yet comfortable fit. The Glycerin 23 is recognized with the APMA Seal of Acceptance, emphasizing its suitability for those with specific foot health concerns.

Comfort and Cushioning Comparison

When it comes to comfort, the ASICS Gel-Excite 11 offers a softer experience with its AMPLIFOAM PLUS cushioning, designed to provide a more comfortable ride than standard cushioning systems. However, the Brooks Glycerin 23 takes cushioning to the next level with its upgraded nitrogen-infused DNA tuned midsole, which adds an additional 2mm of cushioning in the forefoot compared to its predecessor. This results in softer landings and a more responsive toe-off, making it ideal for serious runners. While both shoes prioritize comfort, the Glycerin 23's advanced technology may be more appealing to those seeking superior cushioning.

Fit and Design

The fit and design of the Gel-Excite 11 prioritize breathability and comfort with its engineered mesh upper, which helps reduce the need for additional overlays. This lightweight design enhances flexibility, making it a suitable choice for various activities. In contrast, the Glycerin 23 features a plush, engineered upper that provides a snug, foot-conforming fit. This design reduces hot spots during extended wear, ensuring comfort even on longer runs. While both models offer good fit and design, the Glycerin 23 may better accommodate those who prioritize an adaptive fit for all-day wear.

Performance During Runs

In terms of performance, the ASICS Gel-Excite 11 aims to deliver a smooth running experience thanks to its FLUIDRIDE outsole, which promotes easier strides. However, the Brooks Glycerin 23 is specifically engineered for neutral runners, making it suitable for long distances and various paces. Its wide platform and sculpted midsole ensure smooth transitions from heel to toe, which is crucial for maintaining speed and efficiency during runs. For serious athletes or those who frequently run longer distances, the Glycerin 23’s performance-oriented features may provide a significant advantage.

Price and Value

The ASICS Gel-Excite 11 is priced at $74.95, which is about 53% less than the Brooks Glycerin 23, making it a more budget-friendly option for casual runners or those just starting their fitness journey. This significant price difference does not necessarily indicate a lack of quality in the Gel-Excite 11, as it still provides solid performance and comfort. On the other hand, the Glycerin 23’s higher price reflects its premium materials and advanced cushioning technology, appealing to serious runners who seek durability and enhanced performance. Ultimately, value will depend on individual priorities regarding budget and intended use.

Brand Reputation and Popularity

ASICS, with its Gel-Excite 11, has a solid reputation within the running community, consistently producing reliable footwear. The sales rank of 2,352 indicates a strong level of popularity, especially among casual runners. Brooks, on the other hand, is well-known for their commitment to comfort and performance, and the Glycerin 23's ranking of 4,982 still underscores its appeal. While both brands have established their niches, Brooks tends to be favored among serious athletes, particularly those needing specialized footwear for neutral running. This brand loyalty may influence purchasing decisions, especially for dedicated runners.

Which should you buy?

Choosing between the ASICS Women's Gel-Excite 11 Running Shoes and the Brooks Women’s Glycerin 23 Neutral Running Shoe ultimately comes down to your running needs and budget. The Gel-Excite 11 is an excellent choice for those looking for a comfortable and affordable shoe for casual use or light training, priced at $74.95. In contrast, if you are a serious runner seeking advanced cushioning and performance for long-distance runs, the Brooks Glycerin 23, despite its higher price of $159.99, may be the better option. Each shoe has its strengths, making the final decision dependent on individual priorities regarding comfort, performance, and price.